He filmed corpses of coronavirus victims in China. Then the police broke into his home
He filmed corpses of coronavirus victims in China. Then the police broke into his home
People wear masks in Jingshan Park in Beijing. Beijing canceled many Spring Festival celebrations because of the coronavirus outbreak.
(Wu Hong/EPA-EFE/REX)
By
ALICE SUCHINA CORRESPONDENT
FEB. 3, 2020
12:26 PM
BEIJING —
Masked men in hazmat suits came in the night and knocked on Fang Bin’s door in Wuhan, China, demanding to put him in quarantine.
“You went to such a dangerous place, couldn’t you have been infected?” one of them asked. “What if your sickness spreads to others?”
Fang grew suspicious. He wasn’t sick, and none of them was a doctor.
“My temperature is normal,” argued Fang, who taped the encounter. “Come back with an inspection warrant.”
ADVERTISEMENT
They broke into his home, confiscated his electronic devices and took him away — not to a hospital, but to a police station. Such was the perilous turn for a clothes seller who enlisted as a “citizen journalist” to report on his nation’s secrecy and mishandling of the coronavirus epidemic that has killed at least 360 and infected more than 17,300.
Fang was interrogated about videos he’d posted online, including one in which he spotted eight corpses within five minutes, at public hospitals in Wuhan, the center of an outbreak that has now surpassed China’s death toll during the SARS crisis in 2002-03.
“There wasn’t a single doctor” who interviewed me, Fang said in a phone interview Sunday. “They were all police.”
He said authorities accused him of receiving money from foreign organizations to make online videos, and ordered him to stop posting “rumors” that would “spread panic” online. Fang’s videos were potent: In one he counted several body bags outside a hospital, then went into a room where a man was gasping and sobbing as doctors spoke over a patient who had apparently just died:
ADVERTISEMENT
“It’s over. It’s over,” a voice says.
“Who is he to you?” Fang asked the man.
“My father,” the man cried.
As the new strain of coronavirus that originated in China spreads across the world, authorities are cracking down on Chinese activists’ attempts to investigate the severity of the outbreak. At least 254 Chinese citizens have been
detained, fined or otherwise
punished by authorities for “spreading rumors” about the coronavirus crisis so far, according to Chinese Human Rights Defenders, a nonprofit coalition that tracks human rights in China.
China’s inability to contain the virus in the early days of the outbreak has embarrassed it abroad and ignited a backlash at home as President Xi Jinping tries to calm panic at a time he is consolidating his power. Beijing has attempted to present a face of simultaneous transparency and control, urging foreign diplomats not to evacuate their citizens, and uncharacteristically allowing domestic media a modicum of freedom to report on the outbreak in the last two weeks.
Social media posts criticizing local government officials have been permitted to gather momentum, along with devastating stories of Wuhan and Hubei residents trying and failing to save family members’ lives because of the government’s failure to provide information, resources or access to medical facilities.
Chinese public security volunteers stand at an entrance to their community in Beijing on Friday to register personal information of people returning from outside Beijing after Spring Festival holidays.
(Wu Hong/EPA-EFE/REX)
Harsh criticism has been directed at the local police decision to punish eight whistleblowers, including at least one doctor, who tried to alert the public about a contagious new virus on Jan. 1. They were detained briefly for “spreading rumors” and made to sign a promise that they would stop “making untrue comments” that “severely disturbed the social order.”
ADVERTISEMENT
One of them, Dr.
Li Wenliang, was later diagnosed with coronavirus after treating patients at the frontline.
In an unusual admonishment of a government institution, China’s Supreme People’s Court reprimanded the Wuhan police last week in a WeChat post, saying the whistleblowers should not have been criticized. Li and the others have since been heralded as heroes online and by a high-ranking scientist.
“The coronavirus outbreak requires a swift and comprehensive response that respects human rights,” said Yaqiu Wang, China researcher for Human Rights Watch, in a
report on China’s coronavirus response.
“Authorities should recognize that censorship only fuels public distrust, and instead encourage civil society engagement and media reporting on this public health crisis,” Wang said.
But such openness runs contrary to the Communist Party’s instincts for secrecy and top-down rule. In recent days, censorship and propaganda have again intensified. Doctors and nurses in Wuhan and other localities have reportedly been ordered to stop speaking to the press. Many of the social media posts from sick individuals or their family members have disappeared.
Foreign journalists have been forced to delete video filmed near hospitals and escorted away from affected areas. State news channels meanwhile broadcast stories celebrating China’s fast construction of new hospitals, factories producing face masks to fill the shortage, and medical personnel holding hands with patients in hospital beds, singing patriotic songs to soothe them.
One of the most popular articles in more independent-leaning local media, a report by business publication Caijing about the “
uncounted people” who had died without being tested or reported as potential coronavirus victims, was wiped off the Chinese internet on Monday.
Fang, who runs a traditional Chinese clothing shop in Wuhan, said he’d decided to try “citizen journalism” because of a dearth of reliable information, especially for Wuhan residents stuck in their homes and afraid to go outside.
ADVERTISEMENT
“I wanted to go and see what’s actually happening. It’s what any normal citizen should do,” he said.
He put on a mask and a
hanfu, the traditional outfit he usually sells, and ventured into ground zero.
Fang spent the morning visiting public hospitals in Wuhan and posting videos online. In a video filmed at one of Wuhan’s hospitals, one of the designated locations for treating coronavirus patients, he counted eight corpses within five minutes, including bodies in bright yellow and orange bags.
曾錚 Jennifer Zeng@jenniferatntd
https://twitter.com/jenniferatntd/status/1223639844829769734
Bilingual titles added. 8 bodies in 5 minutes! More are lying inside to be moved out. Somebody secretly shot this video from No. 3 Hopital in
#Wuhan during
#coronarovirus #武汉肺炎
字幕版
某網友秘訪武漢第三醫院,五分钟功夫就見到八具屍體拉走去火化場,而且里面还有。
2,796
11:10 AM - Feb 1, 2020
Twitter Ads info and privacy
2,541 people are talking about this
“How can there be so many?” he said.
That night, the men in medical suits came to his door.
Fear spread across the community of Chinese civil society activists in Wuhan, many of whom have been organizing volunteer efforts to share medical supplies and donations from other “online friends” across the country who don’t trust the official channels.
A group of them went to Fang’s residential compound. Unsure of which building he was in, they shouted his name to the sky in the dark. There was no response.
Panicked, they began sharing videos of Fang’s confrontation online — and as their posts went viral, the police questioners’ tone changed, Fang said.
Around 12:30 a.m., the police let Fang go with just a warning, though they kept his computer. He found a bike, made his way home, and posted another video online, thanking the other activists and calling for more citizens to speak up.
“There’s no use if you’re afraid and you’re begging. The more afraid you are, the more they’ll act like this,” he said. “Only if everyone stands up together — that’s why I say our movement right now, all the people saving themselves, should become all the people saving one another.”
“You’re the ones who saved me,” he said.