stormie
Veteran Member
Woman Sues National Park Service After Being Told She Can't Use Cash to Pay Entry Fee
In a lawsuit filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, Elizabeth Dasburg and two other plaintiffs allege the National Park Service is violating U.S. law by refusing to accept U.S. currency. Children’s Health Defense is financially backing the lawsuit.
childrenshealthdefense.org
In a lawsuit filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, Elizabeth Dasburg and two other plaintiffs allege the National Park Service is violating U.S. law by refusing to accept U.S. currency. Children’s Health Defense is financially backing the lawsuit.
By
Suzanne Burdick, Ph.D.
When Elizabeth Dasburg tried to use cash to pay the entry fee to the Fort Pulaski National Monument in Georgia, she was told that the site, part of the U.S. National Park Service, could accept cards only, no cash.
An employee suggested she go to the local grocery store or “big chains like Walmart” to purchase a gift card. “Since those are cards, we can accept them in leu [sic] of cash,” the site employee wrote.
Dasburg and two others who also were denied entrance to a national park unless they used a card to pay the entrance fee on Wednesday sued the National Park Service, challenging its cashless fee collection policy.
In a complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, the plaintiffs allege the federal agency is violating U.S. law by refusing to accept U.S. currency as entry payment.
Children’s Health Defense (CHD) is financially supporting the lawsuit.
“CHD is excited to support attorney Ray Flores and the plaintiffs in this case to push back against the move toward a cashless society and central bank digital currency,” said Kim Mack Rosenberg, CHD general counsel.
“By forcing people to use credit cards or digital wallets, under the guise of convenience, the National Park Service becomes a player in the surveillance state, undermining park visitors’ privacy right,” Rosenberg said.
Flores told The Defender he found it “appalling” that “these pristine lands are the nation’s testing ground” for a cashless society.
The National Park Service has been implementing and expanding a cashless entry payment system over the past few years, Flores said.
Now, nearly 30 national parks, historic sites and monuments deny entrance to those who try to pay with cash, the complaint said. They accept only credit, debit and other electronic forms of payment, such as ApplePay.
The plaintiffs are asking the court to declare this practice unlawful, which would mean the National Park Service would be forced to let visitors pay with cash. They also seek relief for the cost of the suit, including attorney fees.
Defendants in the case are the National Park Service, the U.S. Department of the Interior — which oversees the National Park Service — and Charles F. Sams III in his official capacity as National Park Service director.
Denying cash violates federal law
According to the complaint, federal statute (U.S. Code Title 31, Section 5103) makes it clear that “United States coins and currency … are legal tender for all debts, public charges, taxes, and dues.”
U.S. currency is essentially “demonetized” when the National Park Service “erodes the dollar’s status as U.S. legal tender,” Flores said.
Catherine Austin Fitts — former federal housing commissioner at the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and publisher of the “Solari Report” — told The Defender, “This lawsuit goes at the very heart of the war to preserve cash, and with it, our human and health freedoms.”
“Removing cash from circulation,” she said, “is an essential step to implementing a complete surveillance state that can shut off our money at will — as we saw happen to the Canadian Truckers — or take our assets and grab our land.”
Flores agreed. “Cashless is a key component — if not the lynchpin — of the surveillance state.”
Austin Fitts encouraged people to support the lawsuit “with your prayers and by using cash and supporting the businesses and organizations that continue to accept and promote cash.”
Cashless policy disadvantages low-income, minority families
Meanwhile, critics of the cashless policy — including CHD President Laura Bono — said refusing to let visitors pay with cash may disproportionately impact lower-income families and people of color.
Only half of low-income households have access to a credit card, according to a March 2022 Federal Reserve Bank of New York report, Bono wrote in a letter to National Park Service Director Charles F. Sams III.
The Government Accountability Office in April 2022 reported that Black and Hispanic households were about 60% less likely than white households to have a bank account. “This should trouble you as greatly as it does me,” Bono wrote.
Flores agreed. “Comforting platitudes of inclusivity, stewardship and welcome are exposed as a fraud when the National Park Service tells the poor and others with hard-earned cash-in-hand to stay out.”
Park service: Cashless fees help us ‘stay safe, secure’
The National Park Service did not immediately respond to The Defender’s request for comment about the lawsuit.
However, according to Mount Rainier National Park’s cashless fee collection FAQ, the park service phased out cash at the park “to be a better steward of our visitors’ dollars.”
The park service cited these reasons for the change:
- Reduces the amount of time park staff spend managing cash (i.e. reduce our administrative burden).
- Improves accountability, reduces the chance of errors, and allows the park to maximize funding available for visitor services and critical projects.
- Reduces transaction times.
- Cashless fee collection helps us stay safe, secure, and effective and allows our rangers to spend more time with visitors.
As of May 3, 2023, the following national parks, monuments and historic sites have switched to, or tested a cashless policy, reported Travel and Leisure:
- Badlands National Park, South Dakota.
- Bent’s Old Fort National Historic Site, Colorado.
- Chaco Culture National Historical Park, New Mexico.
- Crater Lake National Park, Oregon.
- Cumberland Island National Seashore, Georgia.
- Death Valley National Park, California, Nevada.
- Devils Tower National Monument, Wyoming.
- Fort McHenry National Monument and Historic Shrine, Maryland.
- Harpers Ferry National Historical Park, West Virginia, Virginia, Maryland.
- Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park, Hawaii.
- Home of Franklin D. Roosevelt National Historic Site, New York.
- Isle Royale National Park, Michigan.
- Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument, Montana.
- Mount Rainier National Park, Washington.
- Pipe Spring National Monument, Arizona.
- Prince William Forest Park, Virginia.
- Rocky Mountain National Park, Colorado.
- Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore, Michigan.
- Thomas Edison National Historical Park, New Jersey.
- Vicksburg National Military Park, Mississippi, Louisiana.
- Wind Cave National Park, South Dakota.
- Wright Brothers National Memorial, North Carolina.
