Hour Two
Tuesday 7 April 2015 / Hour 2, Block A: Stephen F. Cohen, NYU & Princeton professor Emeritus; author: Soviet Fates and Lost Alternatives: From Stalinism to the New Cold War, & The Victims Return: Survivors of the Gulag after Stalin; in re: Minsk II – nothing signed by the heads of state, but everyone's disengaging from the Donbass front and looking at [federal?] independence for eastern Ukraine. the Atlantic Council website: "What’s at stake isn’t Ukraine; it’s a war for the future of Russia and of European and Eurasian security; . . . we’re only storing up for ourselves and progeny [more] problems]." Tusk, the Pole at the head of the Euro Council, is in a bit of a spot. "The call for federalization . . . " Note that the Donbass was not invited to the constitutional referendum discussion. Doubts about Minsk II extend to Moscow: Sergei Lavrov says it’s blocked by Ukraine, and that all the Euros say that they're under much pressure from Washington. SFC: I've been thinking about Moynihan's "Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not to his own facts." The fact is, the Minsk agreement may be our last chance to avoid war with Russia. The [rhetoric] out of Washington is based not on facts. JB: It’s widely thought that the cease-fire is holding . . . SFC: Six thousands have dies, many have fled, and many are right now lying dying in rubble. Most of those who die are women, children, old people,
Tuesday 7 April 2015 / Hour 2, Block B: Stephen F. Cohen, NYU & Princeton professor Emeritus; in re: Today's NY Times published three pieces on this story – warning the Greeks not to accept money from Russia, and tow other tacks. Omits two factors: How does Putin have cash since the US put heavy sanctions on him? Inconsistent Washington tales. Note that Greece and Russia share confessions. Is there a US policy toward Russia and Ukraine that's splitting Europe? Not clear what'll come of this; but . . . eurozone crisis was financial, now includes political with the Ukraine [mess]. Cyprus & Greece – Niko Anastasiotis is offended by Obama Adm deed; the US ambassador to Cyprus suggested that Mr Anastasiotis was visiting Moscow in connection with the murder of Boris Nemtsov; and the US had to apologize – the State Dept has again commingled policy with [propaganda]. The US ambassador disgraced himself.
Tuesday 7 April 2015 / Hour 2, Block C: Stephen F. Cohen, NYU & Princeton professor Emeritus; in re: The US amb and the Czech president are at odds: "If the Czech president went to Moscow's enormous VE day celebration, 70th anniversary of liberation, then the US will make it unpleasant for the Czech Republic." The president of Ukraine is not Poroshenko but the US proconsuls. Last night, an eminent academic in Canada, head of University of Alberta Ukrainian studies, said that I, Stephen Cohen, was of lower moral stature than a certain Ukrainian who was a known Nazi collaborator and Jew-killer. John Kerry could put a stop to most of this with one classified memo. Poroshenko is a weak, inexperienced and not-clever pol; but US [minions] are sabotaging agreements. He unilaterally announced that there cd be no element of federalism [e.g., states' rights, can pick their own police chiefs, educational leaders, and the like], and Poro demanded that there be only one official language, Ukrainian, not Russian. This is nutty. . . . gerrymandered: the SE speaks Russian; president and parliament voted in by the East and North of Ukraine. Poroshenko does this with powerful backers in Washington. Result: permanently partitioned Ukraine, or else war. I think Americans need to make a decision about this. The facts here are clear, reported by intl media daily that the Ukr army is in tatters, wd need a lot of weapons; that the intact fighting forces are militias, mostly neofascists and some who are clearly fascists – formed into the Ukrainian National Guard. It's this crew that the US will start training this month! The House has voted to send weapons; 48 voted against. Some Americans have connected the dots, that these militias do not represent American views at all. Some wear swastikas on their helmets and speak with admiration of Hitler.
Tuesday 7 April 2015 / Hour 2, Block D: Stephen F. Cohen, NYU & Princeton professor Emeritus; in re: "Much pressure from Washington to abrogate Minsk II." Lavrov says Minsk II would solve Russian-European relations – the US seems to think that would isolate the US. Lavrov also said that Kerry said he supports Minsk II - but all his minions are sabotaging; Lavrov said: "Kerry is detached from reality." Lavrov is the most informed and moderate of Russia's leaders. Russians are baffled – are ht Americans uninformed, or do thy have a plan? Increasingly, Moscow thinks that [collective] Washington has an all-out plan for war against Putin's Russia.
.. .. .. .. ..
OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media Dunja Mijatovic today welcomed new legislation to foster the development of public broadcasting in Ukraine.
Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko today signed a bill amending the public broadcasting law, which includes the legal status of and the basis for the creation of public broadcasting, establishes supervisory and editorial councils and introduces changes to the system of funding.
The bill was adopted by Ukraine’s parliament, the Verkhovna Rada, on 19 March.
“This is one more assertive and important step made by the authorities to transform state media into a public broadcaster in Ukraine,” Mijatovic said. “Public broadcasting should reflect the diversity of the entire population, offer quality content, and practice editorial independence free of the direct and indirect political and commercial pressures.
“I also strongly believe that true and independent public broadcasting has great potential to deter hostile propaganda by setting the standards of truth, pluralism and openness,” Mijatovic said. “I urge the authorities to do their utmost in order to support implementation of the law.”
The Representative commissioned a legal review on a public broadcasting law in 2013 and provided Ukrainian authorities with recommendations. The review is available in Russian at:
http://www.osce.org/ru/fom/104653
The OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media observes media developments in all 57 OSCE participating States. She provides early warning on violations of freedom of expression and media freedom and promotes full compliance with OSCE media freedom commitments. Learn more at
www.osce.org/fom, Twitter: @OSCE_RFoM and on
www.facebook.com/osce.rfom.
1. NATO/US Allegations, accusations, conspiracies against Minsk II: Putin's Ukraine War Is about Founding a New Russian Empire According to Vladimir Putin, Crimea and Ukraine are where the spiritual sources of Russia's nationhood lie. And he “always saw the Russians ...
Putin’s objective, then, can only lead only to a perpetual state of war within the former Soviet space and a state of siege with Europe and the world. That means another Cold War, if not a series of hot wars along Russia’s periphery. Russia has already been a state in a permanent war condition since 1994 when the Chechen war broke out as what used to be called a war of national liberation. Now the entire North Caucasus is aflame with a militant Islamist uprising that Moscow cannot quell and that has become ever more brutal.
The Kremlin’s 2008 war with Georgia, which Putin admitted to planning from 2006, its coercive incorporation of the Georgian territories of Abkhazia and South Ossetia into Russia, and the war with Ukraine all represent a working out of this logic of imperialism and war. Even if the Ukraine war devolves into a so-called frozen conflict, that logic will still be operative. We already have seen how quickly frozen conflicts can become unfrozen and how they corrode civility and democracy throughout their regions. Beyond that, a renewed Russian empire essentially reincarnates the idea that Russia is not safe unless everyone connected to it, and not only its immediate neighbors, is unsafe or insecure. This state can only be preserved then by what the late Russian defense analyst, Vitaly Shlykov, called structural militarization. And we see that happening now with the growth of the defense sector as the rest of the economy shrivels due to sanctions and falling energy prices.
This is what is at stake in Ukraine. It is not just a quarrel over the fate of Ukraine. It is a war for the future of Russia and beyond that for the long-term future of European and Eurasian security. And to the extent that we hide behind rhetoric that masks a deeper inaction or complacency about Russia and Ukraine, we are only storing up for ourselves and future generations a larger continental crisis.
That crisis, even if we ignore it now, will inevitably occur when the unsustainability of this imperial adventure becomes fully clear not to analysts in the West but to the Russian people and their government. For this regime, unlike Gorbachev’s, will not go peacefully. In a country that is arming itself to the hilt, and that possesses nuclear weapons, that is a terrifying future. Thus inactivity today only ensures and accelerates the onset of the much larger conflict that Putin’s action will inevitably bring upon Russia.
Stephen Blank is a senior fellow for Russia at the American Foreign Policy Council. This article first appeared on the Atlantic Council website.
..
Waving Cash, Putin Sows EU Divisions in an Effort to Break Sanctions Mr. Putin has methodically targeted, through charm, cash, and the fanning of historical and ideological embers, the European Union’s weakest links in a campaign to assert influence in some of Europe’s most troubled corners. One clear goal is to break fragile Western unity over the conflict in Ukraine.
On Wednesday, Greece’s new left-wing prime minister, Alexis Tsipras, will be the next to visit Moscow. Ahead of the trip, Mr. Tsipras declared himself opposed to sanctions on Russia, describing them as a “dead-end policy.” On Sunday, Mr. Putin’s efforts to peel away supporters from the European Union opened a new rift, after the United States ambassador in Prague criticized a decision by the president of the Czech Republic, Milos Zeman, to attend a military parade in Moscow on May 9. And in February, Mr. Putin visited Hungary, the European Union’s autocratic backslider, peddling economic deals. Russia has so far been unable to turn such hand-holding into something more concrete against sanctions that require the approval of all 28 European Union members. But pressure for a rupture is building.
Speaking in an interview last week here in Nicosia, the capital of Cyprus, Mr. Anastasiades said Cyprus had grave doubts about Europe’s policy toward Russia and was part of a “group of member states who have the same reservations.” The cracks opening up in Europe’s policy toward Russia have presented a difficult problem for Donald Tusk, the former prime minister of Poland who is now president of the European Council, a body in Brussels that represents the European Union’s 28 leaders. The Russian Embassy in Nicosia reacted with fury last year when Makarios Drousiotis, a part-time historian and presidential adviser, published a diplomatic history that detailed Russian duplicity in its relations with Cyprus. The embassy denounced the book as “politically unacceptable” and criticized Mr. Drousiotis, who lost his job as an adviser to Mr. Anatasiades.
The United States, in contrast, has struggled to get a hearing. When Russia won gushing praise on social media for restructuring its loan to Cyprus, the United States ambassador, John M. Koenig, tried to dampen the enthusiasm with messages posted on Twitter that were widely interpreted as implying a link between Mr. Anastasiades’s visit to Moscow and the killing a few days later of the Russian opposition politician Boris Nemtsov. The Twitter posts set off an uproar, prompting the United States ambassador to issue a contrite statement that his comments had been “misunderstood.”
.. ..
2. Kiev resistance to Minsk II Ukrainian Leader Is Open to a Vote on Regional Power President Petro O. Poroshenko of Ukraine on Monday denounced calls for “federalization” of the country, which Russia has . . . In his speech, Mr. Poroshenko spoke of the historical importance of Pylyp Orlyk, a Cossack nobleman and Ukrainian hetman, or leader, in exile who in 1710 wrote the Bendery Constitution. Many scholars believe it was the first to codify the separation of powers among the executive, the legislature and the judiciary as a democratic standard.
Mr. Poroshenko urged the head of the constitutional commission, Volodymyr Groysman, who is the speaker of Ukraine’s Parliament, to seek input from the Opposition Bloc, the one minority faction in the legislature. It includes former allies of President Viktor F. Yanukovych, who was ousted last year after huge street protests. “I would like very much, and believe it is possible, for the commission to become a unifying platform of all political forces, society, domestic and international experts in working out such important constitutional initiatives required by our society,” Mr. Poroshenko said.
In eastern Ukraine, however, it was clear that Mr. Poroshenko was falling short of that goal. Separatist leaders noted that they had not been invited to join the commission on constitutional changes, and they took issue with Mr. Poroshenko’s remarks, including his insistence that Ukraine would remain a “unitary state” and his declaration that Ukrainian would remain the country’s only official language. “These things are absolutely unacceptable,” Andrei Purgin, head of the Donetsk People’s Republic, told the Interfax news agency. “Everything they now say and do contradicts the Minsk agreements that took so much work to achieve.” As for the commission and the constitutional amendment process, Mr. Purgin told Interfax: “We did not receive any invitations. We don’t have any representatives there.”
Ukraine and Separatists Report 'Intensifying' Skirmishes Near ... But, he said, the Russian-backed separatist group calling itself the Donetsk People’s Republic (DNR) has “started to intensify their activities” in Shyrokyne and in other areas surrounding Mariupol after a period of “relative calm”.
Meanwhile Edward Basurin, a spokesman for DNR, confirmed details of skirmishes between rebels and pro-Ukraine forces near Shyrokyne but insisted it was the pro-Kiev soldiers who had opened fire on DNR forces, not the other way around. "At five in the morning today they fired a machine gun at a GAZelle vehicle which was transporting [our] soldiers. Two people were wounded as a result,” Basurin, who goes by the title of minister of defence in the unofficial republic, told a Donetsk local news site. Mariupol is a major seaport in the Donetsk region and continues to be under Kiev’s control, however DNR leader Alexander Zaharchenko has expressed he would like to “take” the city.
3. European and German hopes for Minsk II UPDATE 2-IMF official sees 'leeway' in judging Ukraine's debt ... Ukraine's officials have set themselves a June deadline to complete debt ... As part of its IMF bailout, Ukraine must comply with a slew of ...
IMF defends huge support for war-torn Ukraine Ukraine's officials have set themselves a June deadline to complete debt restructuring needed to plug a $15 billion funding gap in the IMF program. Many analysts are skeptical that deadline can be met. "We have a fair amount of leeway in how we judge the progress at that point," David Lipton, the IMF's first deputy managing director, said at an event at the Washington-based Peterson Institute. "It would be best if Ukraine and its creditors could reach agreement by that point," he said. "But if we can't make (a decision) in June, we will figure out how to go forward." As part of its IMF bailout, Ukraine must comply with a slew of conditions to get its economy in better shape, including strengthening public finances, repairing bank balance sheets and shaking up its energy sector.
It must do so amid continued uncertainty over its territorial integrity. The government in Kiev struck a ceasefire with pro-Russia separatist rebels eastern Ukraine two months ago, but fighting has continued almost daily. The IMF itself has admitted that efforts to restore Ukraine's financial stability face "exceptionally high" risks, including from creditors balking at the terms of the debt restructuring.Russia holds a $3 billion Eurobond of Ukrainian debt coming due in December, and has said it would not be part of the private sector restructuring. And Kiev may have difficulties persuading all bondholders to agree to write off some debt and accept reduced interest rates or a longer repayment period.
IMF first deputy managing director David Lipton said that a real window for progress has opened "for the first time" after decades of government mismanagement and corruption. As recently as 2013, he said, there was no will among Kiev's leaders to undertake the reforms needed to right its economy, especially to address massive corruption. "Now, Ukraine has the political will, but it has to contend with full-blown economic and financial crisis," Lipton told the Peterson Institu . . .
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...ofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst
4. Kremlin hope for Minsk II Ukraine has key to better Russia-EU relations - Lavrov "The Minsk agreements are being blocked by Ukraine. Thus, Ukraine now holds the key to normalization of relations between Russia and the ... Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko’s attempts to have foreign troops deployed in eastern Ukraine as a peacekeeping mission might be a "tactical loophole," Russia's top diplomat said. Ukraine Today: Slovaks protest Russia's 'imperial and aggressive ...
http://rt.com/news/241441-strategic-bombers-crimea-redeployment/
CRIMEA Several Tu-22M3 (NATO designation ‘Backfire’) variable-sweep wing, long-range strategic and maritime strike rocket aircraft are due to arrive to Crimea as part of global training exercises for the Russian military in the European part of the country.
KALININGRAD Russia’s Central Command is also beefing up its presence in Kaliningrad. The task force in Kaliningrad Region is set to be bolstered with Iskander-M tactical ballistic missile complexes and additional fighter jets and bombers. “The task force in the Baltic region will be enhanced with Iskander missile complexes of the Western military district, the delivery of complexes is going to be carried out by large landing ships of the Baltic Fleet,” said the source.
---Rising talk of and prospect of renewed and larger war, continuing discussion of Minsk II.
--- In that connection, alarming reports of rising power of ultra-neonazi battalions in the UKR
military, with Yarosh/Right Sector appointed to high post. Would another Maidan be neo-fascist?
--- Impact of new cold war on politics inside Russia, both official and opposition, including
culture, etc. A new Moscow Winter?
The Chechen War, Part 4:
http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/143546/nicholas-waller/a-chechen-... ; Thus far, these two groups have not faced each other directly on the battlefield. Kadyrov’s fighters were instrumental in the final assault on Donetsk Airport in January, having fought for months to capture the wrecked hulk of buildings that once made up the passenger terminals. For its part, the Dudayev Battalion has acted as a special operations unit charged with disrupting separatist communications and supply lines, using the small-fire group tactics perfected during intense urban battles in Chechnya. Even if their role remains modest in terms of numbers, however, the presence of these two opposing camps has turned the Ukraine conflict into a proxy war of sorts, further tangling the knot of competing interests and creating repercussions that might reach far beyond the region.
Yanukovych's Choice Alexander J. Motyl Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych has a decision to make. On November 28–29, Ukraine could sign an Association Agreement with the EU that will expand their political and trade ties, security cooperation, and cultural connections. Success or failure to sign the agreement . . .
Rust Belt Rising Yuri M. Zhukov In recent days, the armed conflict in eastern Ukraine has reached a new phase. With a political mandate to use force, and with Russian troops partially pulled back from the border, Petro Poroshenko, the newly elected president, has stepped up his government’s counterinsurgency operations in the . . .
Broken Ukraine Paul Stronski Continued violence between Ukrainian forces and Russian-backed separatists in eastern Ukraine is dashing hopes about last month’s Minsk II cease-fire agreement. February’s terrorist attacks in Kharkiv, Ukraine, and the continued threat of a separatist assault on the strategic port city of . . .