ALERT Regional middleast war thread Israel and Iran at war

Housecarl

On TB every waking moment
FJ
@Natsecjeff
How the Israel Air Force could bring Iran to its knees - analysis

What if Israel finally decides to strike back? What if it decides to take this opportunity to finally bomb Iran’s prized nuclear weapons program?


How the Israel Air Force could bring Iran to its knees - analysis

What if Israel finally decides to strike back? What if it decides to take this opportunity to finally bomb Iran’s prized nuclear weapons program?

APRIL 14, 2024 12:27
Updated: APRIL 14, 2024 17:38



Iran took its best shot (or a very significant one) at Israel with over 100 ballistic missiles, cruise missiles, and over 100 drones, totaling over 300 forms of aerial attack from many different sides and vectors.

What if Israel finally decides to strike back? What if it decides to take this opportunity to finally bomb Iran’s prized nuclear weapons program?

Such a scenario has been gamed out for years, but here is one version of what it could look like.

Several quartets of F-35 stealth combat jets could fly by separate routes to hit sites across the massive Islamic Republic, some as far as 1,200 miles from the Jewish state.

Some of the aircraft might fly along the border between Syria and Turkey (despite those countries' opposition) and then race across Iraq (who would also oppose). Other aircraft might fly through Saudi airspace (unclear if this would be with quiet agreement or opposition) and the Persian Gulf.

The main aim would be to eliminate Iran's air defense​

They might arrive simultaneously or in waves (as Iran did overnight between Saturday and Sunday) to first eliminate the ayatollahs’ air defenses at dozens of Iranian nuclear sites, carefully hand-picked by the Mossad and IDF intelligence.

An Iranian missile system is seen during an Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) ground forces military drill in the Aras area, East Azerbaijan province, Iran, October 17, 2022. (credit: IRGC/WANA (West Asia News Agency)/Handout via REUTERS)
Their job would be to eliminate Iran’s serious air defense shield, a much more sophisticated defense system than anything Lebanon, Syria, or Hamas possesses.

Regardless of whether the F-35s came in unison or in waves, there would almost certainly be a separate wave for Israel’s F-15 eagles, F-16 fighting falcons, and heavily loaded F-35s carrying 5,000-pound American GBU-72 bombs. 2,000 pound and smaller bombs might also be used for a variety of targets.

There might even be additional waves after that to assist in penetrating deep into the ground to destroy Iran’s top nuclear facilities at Fordow and Natanz.

The IDF could also potentially use a significant number of its own surface-to-surface ballistic missiles as well as intelligence-collecting and attack drones.

Fordow’s main chamber is buried some 80 meters underground, a depth that only the 30,000-pound “bunker buster” bombs in the American arsenal could immediately destroy.

But even under the Trump administration, the US has always refused to provide Israel with such bunker busters.

That said, one does not need to entirely eliminate a facility to render it useless. A repeated series of strikes could block Tehran’s access to electric power, bury its entrances and exits, and cut it off from the world.

Such an operation might not be free.

Iran might succeed at shooting down aircraft.

Some aircraft might fail to make the return flight due to fuel issues even if there was some complex midair refueling capability or midway landing spot as part of the plan.

On the positive side, despite the massive number of aerial attacks by the IDF in Lebanon, Syria, and Gaza, which reportedly also included F-15 and F-16 fighter aircraft at times, Israel lost only one F-16 in early 2018 and has never lost an F-35.

Special forces or Mossad agents in Iran to assist close-up could be lost one way or another.

There are also additional facilities that Israel might strike, such as the heavy water reactor at Arak, the uranium conversion plant near Isfahan, research reactors at Bonab, Ramsar, and Tehran, and other facilities where Iran has moved forward on weaponization issues – though these facilities might be a lower priority as they are earlier points in the nuclear weapons cycle.

As of mid-2023, it was also revealed that IDF intelligence formed a new unit of dozens of officers with one goal: to collect and assess intelligence to develop a massive target bank for hitting Iran far beyond just its nuclear program.

The targets were to include key power sources for the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps in order to bring them to their knees much the same way IDF intelligence had collected intelligence for years on an enormous number of Hamas and Hezbollah targets.

Israel might not undertake a huge attack on Iran’s nuclear facilities.

If it does, it might not open up the much larger target bank of IRGC targets.

Maintaining US and allied support is also a crucial value.

On the other hand, the main reason not to attack Iran for years has been the blowback that Jerusalem could receive from Hezbollah, Hamas, and hundreds of drones and ballistic missiles.

Being that most of the worst case scenarios have already transpired – and even worse including Yemen who was not viewed as for sure taking part in a theoretical larger war as they have in fact in the current very real war – there would seem to be a lot less of a reason to hold back at this moment than at anytime in decades.

How the Israel Air Force could bring Iran to its knees - analysis

Arguably the bigger immediate threat to Israel is Hezbollah with the thousands of Iranian supplied missiles with flight times of minutes to targets in Israel followed by the Houthis and the remnants of Hamas then Iran proper.
 

CaryC

Has No Life - Lives on TB
They have won in Ukraine. Now it is pushing forward until the lines break, as they seem to be doing. They may be itching for a lot of payback. Maybe they think Iran might be the place to get it. A considerable number of NATO members may not think that Iran vs Israel, and collateral damage, is a NATO matter. Time will tell.
Just talking and giving opinion, nothing more:

They absolutely have won in Ukraine. It's just a matter of the collective west recognizing it.

Saw an article over at zerohedge this am where an Army guy of some sort was testifying in Congress, that Russia now has the largest Army on the continent. They are a big dog now.

From sources we can't talk about, Russia has "been destined" to move into the Middle East for a while now. Even without that source, it should be at least contemplated, that Russia has pay back on their mind. Against the west. For how they have been treated because of Ukraine. And that a hot war doesn't have to be on the horizon with the west. Just an economic one. And oil is at the top of that list. In conjunction with BRICS+.

While the US came in as the big dog backing Israel, a weakened US, and we really are weak, not being able to supply a small army with 155 shells (what's up with that?????) to an economy that can't support a war. 34 trillion in debt. Mumble mouth and Karens as our leadership. I'm not sure weak is accurate. There is coming a time when the US either can't or won't back Israel (might loose votes ya know) and that will make Russia the big dog in the ME who will back Iran, and then let's see what happens.

Don't think that will be the case in the next few days but maybe Nov. or four years from Nov.
 

colonel holman

Veteran Member
Could be an Iranian war plan. On the first Iranian attack, throw few hundreds lightweight generic drones and missiles at Israel, discovering how Israel defends itself and sap off some of Israel’s (and its allies’) very expensive defensive tools, while expending only low-dollar ordnance. Then fine tune the real Iranian offensive as a response to a measured Israeli offensive revenge response (a response that, as a bonus, looks like it may only go without US active support).

That real Iranian response would be all-out, full-blast, flood-the-zone with 100,000 thousand missiles/drones from Iran and its heavily-equipped allies Hezbollah (120-150,000 of its own missile) and from Shia rebels in Syria and Iraq and Yemen (compared to the mere few hundred incoming during Iran’s first time around launches). No way could Israel defenses keep up with that inundation. Could easily be a ELE for Israel, Especially if US is pissed at Israel for not standing down on their revenge attack, and will not (and cannot) give a timely response on this full-fledged attack. Especially ominous if the Iraqi fundamentalist leaders do not fear nuclear conflagration (or have arranged with Russia for a nuclear umbrella that Washington decides “just aint worth fighting.”

Been mentioned already but that is what I fear is coming
 

jward

passin' thru
Jason Brodsky
@JasonMBrodsky

A move to strike #Iran's regime outside Iranian territory makes no sense to me, especially after Iran fired at Israeli territory. This is more of the same--what #Israel has been doing for years--and not a deterrent message. 1/2
This sounds like U.S. performative responses over the years aiming at shipments and storage facilities. 2/2

Faytuks News Δ
@Faytuks

Read the article and I didn't post it because it's based on conversations before Saturday. Feels outdated.

5:47 AM · Apr 16, 2024
2,637
Views

Jason Brodsky
@JasonMBrodsky

That's my sense.

 

jward

passin' thru
:bwl:






Swords_of_Iron

Nearly 50 survivors of Nova massacre have committed suicide​

Many survivors of the Nova music festival massacre are forcibly admitted to psychiatric wards; other survivors demand: 'Why do we need to prove and explain more in order to receive help?'​

Hezki Baruch
Hezki Baruch
Apr 16, 2024, 12:26 PM (GMT+3)

The State Control Committee on Tuesday held a meeting discussing the bureaucratic difficulties faced by the survivors of the Nova music festival massacre on October 7, as they attempt to receive treatment for their trauma.

Guy Ben Shimon, a survivor of the massacre said, "There are nearly 50 suicides among the Nova [survivors] - that is a number from two months ago. There are many more who are forcibly admitted."

Na'ama Eitan, who also survived the massacre, said, "I participated in a study which checked my heartrate and other parameters and showed me how I really am not okay at all. The average number of hours I sleep each night is two. I spent seven hours under a tree, while terrorists passed beside me and I called the police and asked, 'Where are you? Why is no one coming?' If there is quiet around me, my head is noisy and I go back to there. I need someone to accompany me at all times."



Related articles:
She stressed, "If it weren't for my psychologist, I would not be here. I have friends who have not yet gotten out of bed, and they have no help. Twenty-four treatments? What is that? Nothing! Why do I need to prove to someone what I experienced? Why do I need to prove and explain what happened to me? I was there."

Or Nasa, another survivor, shared, "We don't wake up at night and we can't do anything, and now they come and we need to fill out this form or that form. This could ruin our entire day. We are not able to do anything. A friend stopped working because of a mental breakdown that she experienced, but the National Insurance Institute doctors did not recognize her as suffering a work injury. I need to go to a psychologist but there is an appointment only five months from now."
 

jward

passin' thru
Will Schryver and IntelSky follow
Sharmine Narwani
@snarwani

EXCLUSIVE: "An Iranian military security official has revealed that the US contacted the Islamic Republic, asking the nation to allow Israel 'a symbolic strike to save face' following Iran's retaliatory drone and missile barrage this weekend."
View: https://twitter.com/snarwani/status/1780199469172113877
 

night driver

ESFP adrift in INTJ sea
EXCLUSIVE: "An Iranian military security official has revealed that the US contacted the Islamic Republic, asking the nation to allow Israel 'a symbolic strike to save face' following Iran's retaliatory drone and missile barrage this weekend."
Who ARE these people, and where did they learn their craft (always assuming they learned Some of it SOMEWHERE) .

THIS is essentially delusional behavior. Hell, the Iranian answer vibrated all the way to FLy Over Country Heartland!!!
 

Sacajawea

Has No Life - Lives on TB
I don't understand why they haven't gotten the memo, either ND. The US simply can't "tell" other countries what to do and how high they're allowed to jump anymore. This is the most frustrating and mind-boggling part of all this. At least they did authorize some shoot-downs in Israel's defense.

And if there is any truth in Biden "requesting" Iran to pull their punch... well, Bibi should just stop taking Biden's calls. You don't "stage manage" someone else's war and if you TRY, you become the target for both parties.
 

Mark D

Now running for Emperor.
Will Schryver and IntelSky follow
Sharmine Narwani
@snarwani

EXCLUSIVE: "An Iranian military security official has revealed that the US contacted the Islamic Republic, asking the nation to allow Israel 'a symbolic strike to save face' following Iran's retaliatory drone and missile barrage this weekend."
View: https://twitter.com/snarwani/status/1780199469172113877
That CAN'T be a real story.
 

Wildweasel

F-4 Phantoms Phorever
This “quote” came from a plan to attack an air base that was not fortified, or at least not parked therein. Good for the Israelis.
Then somebody screwed up, because Google Maps shows about 100 Nato-style TAB-V hardened aircraft shelters all around that base. And it's a huge airbase with 5 runways and numerous parallel taxiways usable as emergency runways.

The only aircraft parked outside were some C-130s and 707s. And they look like they were retired aircraft, the way they were parked nose-to-tail on an out of the way taxiway.
 

Donghe Surfer

Veteran Member
View: https://youtu.be/eHayOkXe5ig?feature=shared


Must see.
Many Christians blindly support Israel without understanding the country and how Christians are not truly free there.

Can start around 27:45.
Evangelism is illegal.
Ironic that evangelicals in U.S. wholeheartedly support Israel, yet it is illegal to set up such churches there.
Israel is not a real democracy island in the MidEast like the media and governments portray it. The right for self-determination is only for the Jewish people (no other people), as written in the law.
 

Wildweasel

F-4 Phantoms Phorever
Just to add... I have counted 5 special aircraft have departed Offutt AFB, in Nebraska. TOPCT23-R135, Cobra36-W135, IRON96-E6, HOOVR63-R135,SNOOP34-R135.
All going in different directions.
All on adsbexchange.

Severe weather evacuation like yesterday's report of close to 40 or more planes getting out of town at Altus AFB?
 

mecoastie

Veteran Member
The US money and support says we can.
That is our stick and carrot. The truth is without US military support Israel would be in big trouble. What would have happened to Israel if the US and Jordan hadn’t helped take down those drones and missiles? In addition to what we send them we pay for a lot of the stuff they manufacture.

As for Iran. I don’t see any reason why we wouldn’t ask them. Worth a shot. Israel will retaliate which means Iran will retaliate and on and on. Unless one of them stops we are all in trouble.
 

Wildweasel

F-4 Phantoms Phorever
The Spectator Index
@spectatorindex

BREAKING: Official from Iranian parliamentary national security commission says his country is ready to use a 'weapon we have never used before' if Israel launches retaliatory attack

3:59 PM · Apr 15, 2024
841K
Views
Oh NO!!! Iran is going to unleash its stealth fighter and show the world how stealthy cardboard, fiberglass and Silly Putty can be!
 

Millwright

Knuckle Dragger
_______________
Counting derivatives, we're over a Quadrillion in the hole. Seriously- what money?

The same ersatz money that the whole world is operating on.

d3ef6b4f2ecebffc5af16d01c7f36ba3_w200.gif
 

Dash

Veteran Member
View: https://youtu.be/eHayOkXe5ig?feature=shared


Must see.
Many Christians blindly support Israel without understanding the country and how Christians are not truly free there.

Can start around 27:45.
Evangelism is illegal.
Ironic that evangelicals in U.S. wholeheartedly support Israel, yet it is illegal to set up such churches there.
Israel is not a real democracy island in the MidEast like the media and governments portray it. The right for self-determination is only for the Jewish people (no other people), as written in the law.
This isn’t true. Freedom of religion is guaranteed in Israel.

From embassies.gov.il

The Declaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel (1948) guarantees freedom of religion for all. Each religious community is free, by law and in practice, to exercise its faith, to observe its holidays and weekly day of rest, and to administer its internal affairs. Each has its own religious council and courts, recognized by law and with jurisdiction over all religious affairs and matters of personal status such as marriage and divorce. Each has its own unique places of worship, with traditional rituals and special architectural features developed over the centuries.

https://embassies.gov.il/holysee/AboutIsrael/Pages/Religious-Freedom-.aspx#

Below is an AP article from last year about Netanyahu blocking a bill against Christian proselytizing.

Israeli leader halts bill against Christian proselytizing

Israeli leader halts bill against Christian proselytizing​


JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Wednesday said he would prevent the passage of a proposal by a powerful ally in his governing coalition to punish Christian proselytizing with jail time.

The proposal had raised an uproar with evangelical Christians — one of Israel’s strongest and most influential supporters in the United States.

The bill was introduced in January by a pair of ultra-Orthodox Jewish lawmakers, including Moshe Gafni, who heads the parliament’s Finance Committee. It says soliciting someone to convert their faith should be punishable by one year in prison and solicitation to convert a minor would be punishable with a two-year sentence.

“Recently, the attempts of missionary groups, mainly Christians, to solicit conversion of religion have increased,” it said.

The bill was never advanced, but it drew widespread attention in the American evangelical world this week after All Israel News, an evangelical news site, reported on it.

On Wednesday, Netanyahu announced on Twitter: “We will not advance any law against the Christian community.”

Gafni said he had introduced the bill as a procedural matter, as he has done in the past, and there were no plans to advance it.

READ MORE
Evangelical Christians, particularly in the United States, are among the strongest backers of Israel, viewing it as the fulfillment of biblical prophecy, with some seeing it as the harbinger of a second coming of Jesus Christ and the end of days.

Israel has long welcomed evangelicals’ political and financial support, and it has largely shrugged off concerns about any hidden religious agenda. But most Jews view any effort to convert them to Christianity as deeply offensive, a legacy of centuries of persecution and forced conversion at the hands of Christian rulers. In part, because of those sensitivities, evangelical Christians rarely target Jews.

Joel Rosenberg, editor in chief of All Israel News, welcomed Netanyahu’s announcement, which comes at a time of domestic turmoil in Israel over his plan to overhaul the country’s legal system and rising tensions with the Biden administration over West Bank settlement activities.

“Netanyahu is a longtime and proven friend to the global Christian community and his action today — amidst all the other issues on his plate — is further proof,” Rosenberg said.
 
Last edited:

Abert

Veteran Member
Turkey is NATO. How does that play out?
First NATO - by definition - is a defensive operation. Granted they have taken part in a number of offensive actions attacking other nations FIRST. But in the end there is NO requirement that they act in lock step. Even in the often called out Article 5 - an attack against one is an attack against all - does not require all members to take military action. Even under Article 5 each nation gets to decide on what and how much they will do - they can even sit out the conflict.
As for Turkey - they are foremost a Muslim nation - an attack on another Muslim nation - especially acting in support of Israel would politically be impossible.
 

Doughboy42

Veteran Member
Could be an Iranian war plan. On the first Iranian attack, throw few hundreds lightweight generic drones and missiles at Israel, discovering how Israel defends itself and sap off some of Israel’s (and its allies’) very expensive defensive tools, while expending only low-dollar ordnance. Then fine tune the real Iranian offensive as a response to a measured Israeli offensive revenge response (a response that, as a bonus, looks like it may only go without US active support).

That real Iranian response would be all-out, full-blast, flood-the-zone with 100,000 thousand missiles/drones from Iran and its heavily-equipped allies Hezbollah (120-150,000 of its own missile) and from Shia rebels in Syria and Iraq and Yemen (compared to the mere few hundred incoming during Iran’s first time around launches). No way could Israel defenses keep up with that inundation. Could easily be a ELE for Israel, Especially if US is pissed at Israel for not standing down on their revenge attack, and will not (and cannot) give a timely response on this full-fledged attack. Especially ominous if the Iraqi fundamentalist leaders do not fear nuclear conflagration (or have arranged with Russia for a nuclear umbrella that Washington decides “just aint worth fighting.”

Been mentioned already but that is what I fear is coming
Danger in this scenario is Israel's Samson Option. Then becomes ELE or TEOTWAWKI event. Move into nukes, end with sticks and stones.
 

Wildweasel

F-4 Phantoms Phorever
If it exists it's probably microwave based as described.
I have to wonder if the F-35's full capabilities were demonstrated? There's always been talk that the ECM suite and radar could be used to deliver a microwave pulse to disable the electronics of an attacking aircraft.

Maybe it could be used against missiles as well? Get a radar lock-on, send a pulse and the missile goes out of control. F-35s flying over Iraq would be close enough to get a radar lock shortly after launch and missiles in their boost phase would be moving slowly, so plenty of time for engagement. Maybe even early enough for the missiles to fall on Iran.
 
Last edited:

Millwright

Knuckle Dragger
_______________
I have to wonder if the F-35's full capabilities were demonstrated? There's always been talk that the ECM suite and radar could be used to deliver a microwave pulse to disable the electronics of an attacking aircraft.

Maybe it could be used against missiles as well? Get a radar lock-on, send a pulse and the missile goes out of control. F-35s flying over Iraq would be close enough to get a radar lock shortly after launch and missiles in their boost phase would be moving slowly, so plenty of time for engagement. Maybe even for the missiles to fall on Iran.

Some variation of the CHAMP missile?
 

Abert

Veteran Member
Faytuks News Δ
@Faytuks

There is US intelligence to suggest Israel is weighing a narrow and limited strike inside Iran, source tells CNN
View: https://twitter.com/Faytuks/status/1780219315989495852
Likely for internal political reasons - have to show they are STRONG. But more likely to test Iran's AD Systems to judge if a larger attack could be pulled off.

In this last round the Muslim nations (except Jordan) were neutral - this keeps up and at some point that is likely to change. Never forget Iran has the ability to shut down international Oil shipments through the Strait of Hormuz. Or in support of Iran the Gulf States (BRICS) could pull another Western Oil embargo - LOTS of ways for this to go Sideways - and Fast.
 

Millwright

Knuckle Dragger
_______________
No. Purely internal to the F-35's onboard electronics and not a one-time thing like CHAMP. Limiting factor would be how long the F-35 could stay on-station within range of the Iranian border.

yeah, but the core technology would be closely related, i'm guessing.
 

Wildweasel

F-4 Phantoms Phorever
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender

Lots of Military Equipment including Missiles and Drones have been reported tonight being moved around and into the Iranian Capital of Tehran with several Account claiming that this is Preparation for an Israeli Retaliatory Strike; however, if you Pay Close Attention to the most of the Footage you can see Banners on the several of the Vehicles, indicating that most of this Equipment is likely for Parades on Thursday, the 18th of April, which is Islamic Republic of Iran Army Day.
View: https://twitter.com/sentdefender/status/1780032570224181706
Perfect time for an Israeli response. First warhead targeted to the VIP reviewing stand, with "HAPPY BIRTHDAY AYATOLLAH" written on it.
 
Top