ENER The World Braces For Europe's July 22 "Doomsday"

Blacknarwhal

Let's Go Brandon!
This time, doom is eight days away!

Fair use cited so on and so forth.


The World Braces For Europe's July 22 "Doomsday"

by Tyler Durden
Wednesday, Jul 13, 2022 - 06:11 AM

Two weeks ago, when previewing the scheduled 10-day shutdown of the Nord Stream 1 pipeline - which supplies the bulk of European nat gas usage courtesy of Russia - for maintenance, we quoted from DB FX strategist George Saravelos that if the gas shutoff is not resolved in coming weeks this would lead to a broadening out of energy disruption with material upfront effects on economic growth, and of course much higher inflation, or as he puts it, "beyond the market's worries about slower global growth in recent months, what is unfolding in Europe in recent days is a fresh big negative supply shock."

As such, DB's Jim Reid said that July 22, the day gas is supposed to come back online, could be the most important day of the year: "while we all spend most of our market time thinking about the Fed and a recession, I suspect what happens to Russian gas in H2 is potentially an even bigger story. Of course by July 22nd parts may have be found and the supply might start to normalize. Anyone who tells you they know what is going to happen here is guessing but as minimum it should be a huge focal point for everyone in markets."

Fast forward to today when, one day after the start of the scheduled 10-day shutdown period which has already sent flows through to NS 1 pipeline to basically zero...



... and the market is now focusing on the worst case scenario: what happens if Russia cuts off all gas on July 22, the day even Bloomberg has now dubbed Europe's "doomsday scenario."

Here is a sample of what Wall Street expects to happen then: European stocks plunging 20%. Junk credit spreads widening past 2020 crisis levels. The euro sinking to just 90 cents, before a full-blown recession slams the world's 2nd biggest economy.

And all this power in the palm of Putin's hand, almost as if he knew precisely how much leverage he had back in February while Europe was - as always - completely clueless.

So to help Europe's braindead bureaucrats, where energy policies have been dictated by a petulant Scandianvian teenager and a bunch of German "greens", strategists across Wall Street have tried to put numbers on a scenario that would be unthinkable in normal times. The caveat of course is that there are so many variables, such as the length of any shutdown, the extent of supply cuts, and how far countries would go to ration energy, that anyone’s prediction is a guess at best. Even so, the scenarios are catastrophic.



“The big unknown is how the shock that starts in Germany, Poland and other central European countries will reverberate throughout the rest of Europe and the world,” said Joachim Klement, head of strategy at Liberum Capital. “There simply is no substitute available for Russian gas.”

In an analysis this week (available to pro subscribers), UBS economists laid out a detailed vision of what they see happening if Russia halts gas deliveries to Europe: It would reduce corporate earnings by more than 15%. The market selloff would exceed 20% in the Stoxx 600 and the euro would drop to 90 cents. The rush for safe assets would drive benchmark German bund yields to 0%, they wrote.

“We stress that these projections should be seen as rough approximations and by no means as a worse-case scenario,” wrote Arend Kapteyn, chief economist at UBS. “We could easily conceive economic disruptions that lead to more negative growth outcomes.”

To be sure, markets are already pricing in some of the damage starting with the euro which today traded at a fresh two-decade low and briefly touched parity with the dollar, something it hasn't done since 2002.


Meanwhile, German stocks have lost 11% since June. German gas giant Uniper SE is the biggest corporate casualty, with the stock plunging 80% this year as it seeks a government bailout.

To be sure, even though French and German leaders are warning populations to "prepare for total cut-off of Russian gas", many investors still believe there’s reason to believe Russia will turn gas supply back on when maintenance on the Nord Stream 1 pipeline ends on July 21. But, as UBS points out, if European countries start voluntary gas rationing to fill up on storage, the hit to economic growth will be severe.

“Europe is currently being caught in a vicious circle,” said Charles-Henry Monchau, chief investment officer at Banque Syz. Higher energy prices are hurting Europe’s economy, driving the euro lower. In turn, the weaker euro makes energy imports even more expensive, he said.

The other worry is that the ECB will be unable to do much to help the economy - which is about to slide into a recession - with inflation already running at decade-highs, said Prashant Agarwal, a portfolio manager at Pictet Asset Management.

“I am not sure central bank tools work in this scenario,” he said. “In the past, they had leeway to address the situation because inflation was low.”

Courtesy of Bloomberg, here’s a round-up of other strategist views:

BNP Paribas SA
A full-blown gas disruption would drive the Euro Stoxx 50 to 2,800, about a 20% plunge from current levels, wrote strategists including Sam Lynton-Brown and Camille de Courcel.
They recommend hedges, such as high-quality companies and buying options skew on the European stock index. Auto, industrial and chemical industries will be under pressure, they wrote.
Nomura International Plc
Currency strategist Jordan Rochester has been urging clients to short the common currency since April. If Nord Stream 1 doesn’t resume operations, the euro may drop to 90 cents over the winter, he wrote.
“We believe Europe may fail to build up sufficient gas storage for the winter and this may lead to energy rationing,” he said. “If that’s not an economic crisis, what is?”
JPMorgan Chase & Co.
The moves in European corporate bond spreads would be bigger than the first wave of the Covid pandemic in 2020 if Russia shuts off gas supplies, according to strategists led by Matthew Bailey.
Spreads on high-grade debt may surge to 325 basis points, they wrote. For junk-rated bonds, the spread could widen to as much as 1,000 basis points.
Goldman Sachs Group Inc.
The euro is already reflecting a lot of the negativity, but the currency could fall another 5% if markets price in a full shutdown of Nord Stream 1, said strategists including Christian Mueller-Glissmann. They recommend a defensive allocation, with overweights on cash and commodities.
Bank of America Corp.
Former copper bull Bank of America also slashed its forecasts last week, warning that in a worst-case scenario where Europe experiences widespread gas shortages, prices could plunge to as low as $4,500 a ton. Copper sank 2% to $7,429 on Tuesday.
 

tiredude

Veteran Member
This won't be a whimper. This 'thing' will inevitably go kinetic. Especially with the Sauds cozying up to the Ruskies.

Eta: I don't think doom. More war? Yes.
 

Melodi

Disaster Cat
Normally I try to avoid "date panic" in the doom world. But as a told a friend yesterday, that changes when the dates really are important deadlines for something that either will or will not happen.

During this time period there are two of those:

1. On July 22, Russia either will turn the gas pipeline back on for gas going to Europe or it will not. No one knows for sure what they will do, a lot depends on what happens in the next few days.

2. THIS Friday, the 15th, the Russian Duma is meeting, and Putin (or the Duma) either will ask to formally declare war on Ukraine or they will not ask to formally declare war on Ukraine.

Those are very concrete things that either will or won't happen and number 2 might affect and help decide number 1.

I can also assure people that the shutdown of the pipeline was preplanned and I gather it happens every year, they do it in Summer because it is the time when gas is least needed and usually the tanks are mostly full (they are not this year).

But the breath holding is over the topic of will Russia turn the gas back on when they are supposed to or will they simply just shut things down. There is also the scenario where Russia turns the pipeline back on for now but shuts it back down in the Fall just as the cold weather is starting. That would be a different date though, and not part of this particular potential dooms day.
 

Dystonic

Senior Member
It looks like Putin has been playing chess after all. His publicly repeated stated goal is NATO back to the old pre 1999 borders. And he can create a “dark winter” if he doesn’t get it. He doesn’t want a nuclear war, just the USSR sphere of influence back.

We should be taking notes and shoring up the Western Hemisphere.Get out of a lot of countries that hate us and since we’re gonna spend the money anyway, spend it here. I love the USA and at the same time our closest neighbors don’t like us. If we cut off one middle eastern monarch and invested that in Mexico, we could make them an ally. I know, silly idea to try and buildup a country we share a border with.
 

Melodi

Disaster Cat
The point about Mexico is a very good one, especially because they are in effect at the moment a "failed state." Most Americans don't realize that most of Mexico is now run by rival warlords (called gangs but they are more like the mercenary armies of the high Middle Ages) and that the central government has very little control, none in some areas.

That is extremely dangerous to have on your borders, for one thing, if battles are raging - NOTHING will stop terrified people from racing to what they think of as safety. Even shooting at a fleeing population won't stop them, it just kills some of them.

Not only that, but the territorial battles won't just stay in Mexico - they have already spread to parts of Central America and if the US continues to break down, they will spread into the American South West. They have already done so on occasion, but so far the border patrol has watched full battles (including one I saw films of with a few tanks) from the relative "safety" of the border stations.

History says that will break down if something doesn't change.
 

Dobbin

Faithful Steed
Well, that's what you get when you get in bed with your ENEMY. Europe never should have depended on Russia for anything and now they are stuck. Putin owns them.
But - Greta MUST be listened to.

Shut down those Ruhr Valley industries and those environmentally benign nuclear plants (until they aren't) and - MOST IMPORTANT - saddle yourself with an unworkable (but Woke) environmental energy plan.

That is - pay no heed to those widows & orphans who wouldn't be alive EXCEPT for the technical largess of your current capabilities. In Greta's view they should be dead already.

"From the mouths of babes - is not necessarily the answer to life."

The young are by their nature better at questions - than at answers.

Dobbin
 
It looks like Putin has been playing chess after all. His publicly repeated stated goal is NATO back to the old pre 1999 borders. And he can create a “dark winter” if he doesn’t get it. He doesn’t want a nuclear war, just the USSR sphere of influence back.

We should be taking notes and shoring up the Western Hemisphere.Get out of a lot of countries that hate us and since we’re gonna spend the money anyway, spend it here. I love the USA and at the same time our closest neighbors don’t like us. If we cut off one middle eastern monarch and invested that in Mexico, we could make them an ally. I know, silly idea to try and buildup a country we share a border with.
Mexico is NOT our ally. They are a tyrannical cartel run crime syndicate and a communist one at that.
 

Dystonic

Senior Member
Mexico is NOT our ally. They are a tyrannical cartel run crime syndicate and a communist one at that.
I know they are not an ally. And Canadians think we’re loud mouthed morons. I’m suggesting that instead of sending money to those who really really hate us, since congress will be printing the money anyway, why not try to actually win over a neighbor we share a border with. Yeah a lot of that money will make the wrong people rich. But with Mexico they’d be a better bought ally than some sheik who wants to use your skull as an ashtray.
 

Melodi

Disaster Cat
Mexico is NOT our ally. They are a tyrannical cartel run crime syndicate and a communist one at that.
No, but the point is, they could be if, or perhaps it is better to put it that they could have been; if the US had been more focused on the situation in their own backyard than they were with lots of Middle Eastern and now European adventures.

There have been Mexican Presidents in the past who were quite pro-US and practically begged for help in setting up jobs and factories there that would help keep their people home. The current guy is not very pro-US but then he is really the President of Mexico City and the nearby area, the War Lords control other areas.

And until the US military and public realize they ARE Warlords, this will only get worse; it may already be to late to do very much but strengthen the border and hope for the best. That didn't work out so well for the Vatican, which eventually had no Papal States at all.
 

Kathy in FL

Administrator
_______________
Mexico is NOT our ally. They are a tyrannical cartel run crime syndicate and a communist one at that.

I always wonder at people when they seem to think that once illegals cross the border they will suddenly stop acting like illegals and follow US laws and respect our way of life.

Got news, they don’t and won’t and it isn’t even on their radar. You can’t fix stupid and you can’t fix the problem by playing by their rules.
 

Dystonic

Senior Member
No, but the point is, they could be if, or perhaps it is better to put it that they could have been; if the US had been more focused on the situation in their own backyard than they were with lots of Middle Eastern and now European adventures.

There have been Mexican Presidents in the past who were quite pro-US and practically begged for help in setting up jobs and factories there that would help keep their people home. The current guy is not very pro-US but then he is really the President of Mexico City and the nearby area, the War Lords control other areas.

And until the US military and public realize they ARE Warlords, this will only get worse; it may already be to late to do very much but strengthen the border and hope for the best. That didn't work out so well for the Vatican, which eventually had no Papal States at all.
Yes, Thank you Melodi! That’s exactly where I’m going with this. Reverse divesting from China bringing not quite so cheap labor would also be huge win. I’m thinking Trump renegotiating NAFTA large is where we should be focusing. Back to the original point of the thread, Putins goal is regional pre 99 NATO borders. We should be learning how to fix our own hemisphere.
 

Hfcomms

EN66iq
Owner says his wood pile is "looking better & better."

Dobbin

In spades to that or is it in horseshoes? Still cook with propane but can do that on the wood stove too if need be and the woodlot is right outside the door. I might get sore but I will stay warm. And that is the nice thing about heating with wood as it warms you several times. Cutting it, limbing and bucking it, stacking it dragging it in the cabin and then heating with it.
 
No, but the point is, they could be if, or perhaps it is better to put it that they could have been; if the US had been more focused on the situation in their own backyard than they were with lots of Middle Eastern and now European adventures.

There have been Mexican Presidents in the past who were quite pro-US and practically begged for help in setting up jobs and factories there that would help keep their people home. The current guy is not very pro-US but then he is really the President of Mexico City and the nearby area, the War Lords control other areas.

And until the US military and public realize they ARE Warlords, this will only get worse; it may already be to late to do very much but strengthen the border and hope for the best. That didn't work out so well for the Vatican, which eventually had no Papal States at all.


Were they our ally in WW1? WW2? Korea? Viet Nam? anything?
Take out the cartels
 

Dystonic

Senior Member
Were they our ally in WW1? WW2? Korea? Viet Nam? anything?
Take out the cartels
Then maybe it’s time we do something other than buy drugs and visit resorts. Take an annual payment to an African warlord and help develop the border states on their side. Give them a reason to like us and change the perception of arrogant Gringos. Give them a reason to be less cozy with communism.

Putin controlling the oil supply. He’s telling everyone to roll back from Russias sphere of influence. He doesn’t want the world, just the Soviet hegemony back. We should be thinking likewise is my argument. If we wisely wanted that, we would work south nation by nation and cutting off those who really hate us.
 

Groucho

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Or europe could have ignored the US and made russia a friend ..... which is more important, SWIFT or energy?
Well stated. This whole kerfuffle didn't have to happen. However, too similar to 1914, TPTB made all the wrong decisions and we're starting to slide towards a catastrophic climax.
If we don't get vaporized, it may be a very cold winter. Glad we picked up another ton of coal. Naturally, if we slip into war, that coal won't mean sh*t to a tree.
 

Abert

Veteran Member
Other possibility - Russia could make the EU - EAT CROW - and if they want GAS - NS-2 is fully operational - just have to turn it on! Would put them in a political bind - activate NS-2 or watch Germany and the EU spiral into a long cold winter and economic depression.
Would be fun to watch the political dance the EU would be forced to do - regardless of which option they take!
 
Top