ECON Texas Dem suggests Black people shouldn't pay taxes as form of reparations: 'Puts money back in your pocket

20Gauge

TB Fanatic

A House Democrat recently suggested that Black Americans should be exempt from paying taxes as a form of reparations, but she admitted that the plan may not be a success as many within the community who are poor "aren’t really paying taxes in the first place."

The comments from Rep. Jasmine Crockett, D-Texas, came during her appearance on an episode of the "Black Lawyers Podcast," which was released Tuesday.

During the interview with host J. Carter, Crockett recalled a proposal from a celebrity to exempt Black Americans from paying taxes, and said she thought to herself that it was "not necessarily a bad idea."


Though she could not remember which celebrity offered the proposal, Crockett said, "I'd have to think through it a lot. One of the things they propose is Black folk not have to pay taxes for a certain amount of time because, then again, that puts money back in your pocket."

"But at the same time, it may not be as objectionable to some people [as] actually giving out dollars," she added.

Crockett seemingly implied that reparations are much needed for the Black community in order for it to advance.

"So many Black folk, not only do you owe for the labor that was stolen and killed and all the other things, right, but the fact is we end up being so far behind," she said.

Crockett then admitted that the plan may have a shaky foundation as some people within the community are not "paying taxes in the first place."

"If you do the no-tax thing, for people that are already, say, struggling and aren't paying taxes in the first place —" Crockett said, before Carter suggested "it doesn't matter to them" and that "they may want those checks like they got during COVID" rather than a tax exemption.


"Exactly," Crockett responded.

Crockett also said during the interview that she believes there should be some sort of consistency between federal and state governments when it comes to reparations for Black people, saying that if there's not, then "everybody’s gonna run to whichever state and be like, ‘Yo, I need mine.’"

"We don’t want to see that — this is definitely something that needs to be thought through," she said.

Crockett, who has represented Texas's 30th Congressional District in the House since 2023, also took aim at individuals "that aren’t even willing to do the studies, aren’t willing to invest to make sure we can roll this out the right way."

Crockett is up for re-election in November and will take on libertarian candidate Ken Ashby in an effort to retain her post in the House.

A handful of Democrat-led states have considered dolling out reparations to certain residents, including California and New York.


In California, cities like San Francisco and Los Angeles have discussed giving reparations to Black residents. In February, California lawmakers introduced a reparations package to the state assembly, including 14 bills they claim will help support Black communities across the state following historical mistreatment.

Members of California's Legislative Black Caucus said the 14 reparations bills seek a formal apology for slavery and other human rights violations from the governor and legislature, and the return of property taken in race-based cases of eminent domain, among other restitution. The bills are intended to be just the first legislative actions in an effort that will likely span years.

Last December, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul signed a bill that established a commission to research the best ways to offer reparations to descendants of slaves in the state.

The New York-based commission, as lauded by one Democratic state senator, is tasked with "examining the legacy of slavery and its lingering negative effects on people currently living in the State of New York, with the goal of issuing a report comprised of recommendations for appropriate action to address these longstanding inequities."
 

Dobbin

Faithful Steed
Generally IRS "Deductions" have previously been offered on the basis of "general things government wishes to be encouraged among society." Yunno. Like a mortgage deduction (i.e. home ownership), like educational deductions (i.e. self-improvement), like charity (lessens the load on government welfare programs) even "standard deductions" which include a whole cart load of deductions formerly allowed, but combined together as a group because they're widely taken and constitute an "average."

But - isn't a "Black Folk Deduction" in its foundational basis "discriminatory?" All those other deductions can be taken by ANYONE to whom the deduction applies - and there is no other fence to be jumped other than applicability.

For a White human, the Black Folk Deduction would be a four board fence. Near impossible to jump even with a running start.

And, in the interest of fairness, why should a "reparation" on the basis of one's skin colored be offered at all? A war was fought and humans died on both sides of the argument, which is kind of in its place like the ultimate human reparation?

Methinks "pandering alert."

Dobbin
 

Quiet Man

Nothing unreal exists
1. Blacks were just as involved in selling slaves as whites -- Who sold them in Africa in the first place? Yes, blacks.
2. Take a finer microscope to who the 'whites' were that sold slaves -- In the main, they were the jewish bankers and associates.

ETA: In the main, the 'reparations' meme is largely bogus, and, like 'woke', is just another part of the Cabal plan to diminish our society. Don't let them con you with poorly-defined words and redacted history. And, by god, please stop listening to the MSM, which are 98% cr*p.
 
Last edited:

llknp

Senior Member
This all part of a long con being perpetrated on this country. They say things like this just see what we will tolerate. They also say things like this as a smoke and mirror show to hide things. All words, no action.
 

Publius

TB Fanatic
It would make a difference for 10% to 15% of the black population in the country, but for the other 85% will not make any difference to them as they do not pay any taxes to begin with.
 

BornFree

Came This Far
The obvious answer to all of this is that if they want to play this game then Blacks should be paying reparations to white people. So many white people died in order to free them in the revolutionary war. More than any other war.
 

20Gauge

TB Fanatic
Generally IRS "Deductions" have previously been offered on the basis of "general things government wishes to be encouraged among society." Yunno. Like a mortgage deduction (i.e. home ownership), like educational deductions (i.e. self-improvement), like charity (lessens the load on government welfare programs) even "standard deductions" which include a whole cart load of deductions formerly allowed, but combined together as a group because they're widely taken and constitute an "average."

But - isn't a "Black Folk Deduction" in its foundational basis "discriminatory?" All those other deductions can be taken by ANYONE to whom the deduction applies - and there is no other fence to be jumped other than applicability.

For a White human, the Black Folk Deduction would be a four board fence. Near impossible to jump even with a running start.

And, in the interest of fairness, why should a "reparation" on the basis of one's skin colored be offered at all? A war was fought and humans died on both sides of the argument, which is kind of in its place like the ultimate human reparation?

Methinks "pandering alert."

Dobbin
The fact it is being suggested tells us how far we have fallen......
 

Imrik

Veteran Member
Let’s open this can o worms. There are white families, who are owed a LOT more for various other issues.

My French ancestors… Huguenots. Pay up Catholic Church/french government.
You owe us a LOT of money.
See. We all get rich!!!!
 

WTSR

Veteran Member
What about descendants of veterans of volunteers that fought for the North in the civil war? We owe nothing to anyone.
 

ssbn642blue

Veteran Member
Sure!
Of Course!

That way, they'll have more disposable income to spend on bling & other such "essential, must-have items" but whitey can contribute taxes to fund "gib-me-dat" govt. programs.

Another example of "New Math"
And that, IS MY WHITE PRIVILAGE.
 
Top