…… Replacement Windows for home

Buick Electra

TB2K Girls with Guns
I Need to replace my wooden casement, (crank out), windows that were put in when the house was built in 1970 as the wood has rotted away and the guest bedroom gets a nice 18 degree breeze billowing through there in the winter, I too feel a nice breeze flowing over my head in the winter. My biggest energy-sucker is the sliding glass door that's in between the family room and the porch which has no insulation whatsoever, you can actually see the heavy weighted drapes flowing back and forth up against that sliding glass door even though I have door snakes on it. Both estimates from my first contractor and Window World are $2500 for the sliding glass door.

I've decided to do the replacement windows because I'm losing heat and air. I was an on 'Budget Balance Payment plan with my utility company, where the bill right before they switched over to Spring stated I was $118 ahead. Then my next bill comes and says I owe then $500 :gaah:
Even when I call them and the tried to explain WHY, I still don't understand, so yesterday I called them up and had them get me off the budget plan and just direct bill me for what I use.

That said I'm taking a poll on the manufacturer and QUALITY of windows you have a nd would recommend :shr:

I've already met with a contractor who said because I currently have casement windows I can't replace with sash windows - something about widening or encasing those original frames which would add more labor and that it was best I just replace casement for casement. They use Great Lakes Windows - Echosmart. I asked him to break the prices down by room because I might have to peace-meal this project together. When I got his quote, this is what I received.....

Window Quote.JPG

Then my washing machine repairman recommended Window World to me, saying they were no pressure and have been very happy with their windows for the last 5 years and had never has a problem with them since. Thinking Window World sounded like something out of a SNL sketch, like Broccoli City, I was a bit leery but scheduled them for an estimate.

While waiting for Window World to arrive my first contractor calls and says they don't make the same size picture window that I currently have up, and that I will have to go to a smaller picture window. My current window is 67" in length and 47" in height. I didn't think that was out of the norm but he did. I told him I would mention this to the other 2 contractors that were also coming to give me estimates and then there was a pause, then a "Hold on a minute" and then he came back on the line saying they maybe COULD preserve the size of my picture window. (Ahhhhh, Haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!)

So Window World (WW) arrives , starts measuring then asks me what I want: Casement or sash windows. I tell him I would love to have those sash windows you can just flip inside to clean, rather than having to go outside on a ladder but that I was told by my prior contractor I couldn't have sash windows because this house was built out for casement windows. This guy just shook his head and told me I was dealing with the sales guy who wanted me to order the most expensive windows for His commission. He mentioned something about "wrapping" but that it would be no problem to replace the casements with the sashes. He did say the casement windows were the most expensive, but also hardest to break in to, but then again he stated, "If someone is intent on breaking into your home, neither a casement or a sash window will stop them. . IN my case they'd probably throw a big old rock through my picture window and ....Viola! They're in!

(3) of my 7 casement windows look like this....

My window.JPG

Then I have an awning window in each bedroom

Awning window.JPG

My choice is to put another crank-out awning window in or a slider and I can tell you the horror stories I've heard on the sliders so it looks like I'll have to replace awning for awning at $770 each Praising God there's only 2 of those and that I have 7 windows TOTAL to replace, including my sliding aluminum glass door. (We had 32 windows at the farm)

So WW gives me the estimate for the crank out/Casement windows with placebo wood grain on the insides and that estimate came to $18,259. I asked him mow much it would be if I went with the casement with NO WOODGRAIN and instead just white. That knocked of $2500, so now I'm down to $15,758 on the casement windows.

Then he drew me up a contract for the shash windows, just white - no color and they come to $13,860

Now, the have a lifetime warranty were all replacements and labor are covered for the lifetime you own the windows. A neighbor kid hits a baseball through the window, they will come fix it free of charge, but if a tornado takes out my window, my insurance will be paying them to come and clean up and reinstall new windows. If I ever sell this place my warranty, if the seller wants to buy it would cover them for free replacements but the labor does not go to them. That's only for the original purchaser.

They offer financing through Wells Fargo : an 18 months with 0 interest and you start making payment the following month they finish the job and be sure to pay it off in that 18 month time from or else the remainder of the balance will then have a 23% interest tacked on to it.

They also offer 50 months at 8%
And 120 months @ 10%

I have one more window contractor coming tomorrow and I'll see what windows they are pimping. and the cost. At least with WW I have 12 neighbors I plan to kibitz with about how their WW windows are doing and if they've noticed a difference with the heat and cold in their home.

If anyone knows of a really excellent window, would you please let me know ASAP? Just don't bother with the Pella or Anderson windows WHICH USED to be decent, but seem to have gone the way of china, sacrificing quality control.
 
Last edited:

Dobbin

Faithful Steed
then there was a pause, then a "Hold on a minute" and then he came back on the line saying they maybe COULD preserve the size of my picture window.
This is what is known as "using up available stock."

MANY windows are bought "off size" by contractors - a wrong size delivered by accident, a bad house plan forces another size to be used making the ordered window surplus, or something that someone had left over for whatever reason, but has no destination.

There is an active market in "surplus new windows." All looking for homes and bought "cheap" by a contractor - who then charges current "list" price. Think $ in contractor's pocket.

Owner says Marvin, Pella, Anderson are all equivalent. Other brands are good too but its more hit or miss. Daughter's house was retrofitted with a Home Depot replacement window which originally was an Anderson creation, but now is HD's own brand - they're good too.

And make a distinction between "replacement windows" - which use the old casing in place - and "REPLACEMENT WINDOWS" which replace the casing in addition - which sounds like what you want.

The market used to be limited to certain sizes in the latter - but now almost any window, replacement or REPLACEMENT are made to order.

Unless of course your contractor claims that "that size isn't made today" and "I'll have to make up the woodwork around the window - which is more work (think $) for him. And he gets rid of a houseful of windows.

Owner would say you're smart to do your homework ahead of time on this.

Dobbin
 

Nich1

Veteran Member
Wow...I had no idea replacement windows would be so expensive. But...I'm out of the loop on things like that so I shouldn't be surprised. Maybe some of the price helps finance all the TV ads!

I surely do hope you can find the solution that won't send you to the poor house. I'm already there and it's not bad. :-)
 

naegling62

Veteran Member
On a note about windows. The house I grew up in was built in 1963. It has never had any windows replaced, it's single pane design. My house I bought in 85(?) with double pane windows has had every one go bad. The house I'm in now, built in 2004 with Norco double pane windows, are starting to turn white. Any ideas?
 

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
Please note that whenever asking for assistance from the members to use the HELP prefix. Please remember this moving forward. Thanks!

Chamged
 

tno5

Senior Member
I had all the windows replaced in my 1940's home with the Andersen brand. Double pane and they do flip inside so that you can clean. They were I guess vinyl outside and natural wood inside so I could paint them the color I wanted and I got to pick what type of metal as the locks. Been very happy with them and it's been probably 15 years.
 

Dux

Veteran Member
On a note about windows. The house I grew up in was built in 1963. It has never had any windows replaced, it's single pane design. My house I bought in 85(?) with double pane windows has had every one go bad. The house I'm in now, built in 2004 with Norco double pane windows, are starting to turn white. Any ideas?
If I understand you correctly, they lost their seal and are fogging up. Once in a while I find vendors that will fix them, but normally I have to replace them.
 

Old Greek

Veteran Member
I am near finishing a full restore on an 1836 log home. I added a 48x18 addition to the rear of the home for great room/kitchen, etc. I used Mezzo windows and sliding door (9 foot). 13 windows and one sliding door. A mix of double hung and casement. After much investigation (I am a general contractor) I used Mezzo. They offer a triple glaze option which I used in all units (three panes of glass). Windows are vinyl. I have installed these windows in 4 customers' homes (one with a 12-foot sliding door) and they all love them. Super quiet and outstanding insulation package. Worth looking into. JMHO
Good luck with your project!
 
Last edited:

Meemur

Voice on the Prairie / FJB!
We used Window World, excellent product, unreal insulation factor, and lifetime warranty

Another vote for Window World. The heat bill of the previous owners was something like $255 in January and $65 for me after I installed the windows (NOT budget utilities, actual cost). Now, I keep my house at 68 during the day and 62 at night during the winter and they may have had it 80 degrees, but until MidAmerican drastically increased the rates, I never had a heat bill over $100, even when it was -10.

The new windows greatly decreased drafts. I still have really cold floors, but that's on me: I need to insulate the basement ceiling at some point.
 

Firebird

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Wow...I had no idea replacement windows would be so expensive. But...I'm out of the loop on things like that so I shouldn't be surprised. Maybe some of the price helps finance all the TV ads!

I surely do hope you can find the solution that won't send you to the poor house. I'm already there and it's not bad. :-)
They are stupid expensive!! Replacement for our house was $24,000
 

WFK

Senior Something
MW lost a class action suit because of vinyl clad wood windows leaking behind the cladding and the wood rotting behind it.
This house has 12 MW casement windows needing replacement. MW is out of business. I am following this thread closely to see your comments on quality of windows. I do still think Anderson Windows are much better, never mind the earlier "China" putdown.
 

thereisnofork

Veteran Member
I don't know if you can get Milgard in your area. 30 year warranty, had a front window fail after 12 years, new window installed for free with no problems. However, only vinyl frames available. They do make all types of slider and casement windows as well, and curved windows on custom order. Located in Tacoma, WA.
 

Josie

Has No Life - Lives on TB
BE...converted a screened in patio to a sunroom about five years ago. The garage next to the screened porch started to sink and I had to have that shored up. While the ground was already torn up, I figured I might as well do the conversion. Anyway, my contractor really pushed the Pella windows and doors because that's what he's had the best luck within his years of building. I met with the Pella people, and I will agree that they are good windows, but they are also the most expensive and if I hadn't already spent $12K jacking up the garage, I might have gone with them. I ended up with and Anderson slider ($1000 at the time) and a local company Tempco for the windows. I have been more than happy with my choices. The Tempco windows are a marked improvement on the old Andersons I have through the rest of the house. They were $500 per window for a double sash that can be opened inside to clean the outside of them.

My suggestion is to talk to an independent building contractor. They probably have the most experience with windows and will probably give you objective advise.
 
Last edited:

energy_wave

Has No Life - Lives on TB
How bad is the rot? You should be able to just replace the bad window sash or rebuild the rot with wood epoxy.

My brother had a contractor quote vinyl windows on his small NC house and was told 14 k to install replacements. Well, seeing we were in business as contractors who did everything years ago, he knew from the start he was getting ripped off, so he haggled with the guy who called his boss and wouldn't you know, he dropped the price to 7k. That was still a BS price so my brother asked around and found a local handyman who replaced every window with vinyl replacements for around $2,400.00 L&M.

Vinyl windows cost around $150.00 to $200.00 and take a half hour labor to install.

Wood crank out sash can be replaced fairly cheap. Just take the window to a glass service and see if they can do it.

My other brother bought a condo in SC and his 3 section SGD has a cloudy middle panel and was quoted 5 grand to replace the entire door. He called me and I told him, just get the middle glass replaced and he did for around 500 bucks.

Always get several quotes and report the scammers.
 

winston

Contributing Member
Don't know if they will work for you, but i used Indow Windows on two houses - hard to believe the improvement. But you will have to decide if they are appropriate for you.
 

cetansa

Senior Member
I haven't used these guys or their windows but have heard good things. They were trying to hire me but I resisted because, well, oregone. Bend used to be awesome b4 well it was a good few years ago.
 

Buick Electra

TB2K Girls with Guns
Thanks to you all!!!

Although I would LOVE to get this done all at once, I've decided to just replace the biggest energy-sucker right now, my sliding glass door through Window World. So that's $2123 for a triple pane slider. What can I say? I just relish their lifetime warranty of $0 out of pocket for repairs and labor which I won't get if I hire a handyman to install from a box store....because if something is going to screw up, it will with me. I told the rep I'm just going to have to wait and get the rest of the windows done at a later date. (I will do so when I can pay for it all in a check and not have to finance).

In the meantime, I've been and will continue to send neighbors and friends here who have expressed interest in replacing their windows so they can see all the helpful suggestions. You guys are the best! THANK YOU!
 

energy_wave

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Thanks to you all!!!

Although I would LOVE to get this done all at once, I've decided to just replace the biggest energy-sucker right now, my sliding glass door through Window World. So that's $2123 for a triple pane slider. What can I say? I just relish their lifetime warranty of $0 out of pocket for repairs and labor which I won't get if I hire a handyman to install from a box store....because if something is going to screw up, it will with me. I told the rep I'm just going to have to wait and get the rest of the windows done at a later date. (I will do so when I can pay for it all in a check and not have to finance).

In the meantime, I've been and will continue to send neighbors and friends here who have expressed interest in replacing their windows so they can see all the helpful suggestions. You guys are the best! THANK YOU!

Is Window World local or a franchise or a national chain. I've never heard of them and a Google search... I see complaints at the BBB.

 

sy32478

Veteran Member
I am in the middle of replacing out casement windows too and the quotes are more outrageous than what I had guessed and what I had guessed had me delay this project for >20 years.

Intestitinal Fortitude is correct. The contractor is the most important part of the equation. The best windows won't help if you get them installed by shoemakers and scam artists. Good contractors are not cheap, but they are cheaper than paying for the job and then paying someone else to fix it. Check on local Facebook groups and other social media for people who have been happy with local contractors.

Andersen and Pella are the top windows and the prices reflect that. That is another reason it has taken so long to get around to replacing windows that needed replacing when we bought the place in '99. Also - there may be a LONG lead time in getting the windows. We were told 12-16 weeks depending upon the contractor and the brand. Most any size window can be replaced so don't let someone trying to palm off odd leftovers convince you otherwise.

I hope that when ours are done this fall (yes - between ordering delays and contractors being busy, that is when it is scheduled), I hope we see the kind of savings that Meemur has.
 

Jerry

Senior Member
Another vote for Milgard and also for Jeld-wen, both vinyl.
If memory serves, Milgard has a sale every August (?) on their products. Worth planning around.
Might be worth inquiring about the brands you are looking at. Good Luck on your efforts.
 
Top