HEALTH Local Pastor: I must choose how long I want to live, and how

FarmerJohn

Has No Life - Lives on TB
The subjects euthanasia and withdrawal of care have recently stimulated some good discussion here. I offer you this guest column rom my local paper, one of a long series by Tom Swift on the subject of his decline.

TOM SWIFT • OCTOBER 3, 2010

I have ALS and have a decision to make. I have to decide how long I want to live.

ALS (Lou Gehrig's Disease) is a neuromuscular disease that gradually destroys the muscles of its victims. Most people with ALS die when their diaphragm and intercostal (between the ribs) muscles become so weak they can no longer breathe properly. As a result, carbon dioxide builds up in the bloodstream, they fall asleep, and they do not wake up.

A way to delay this event is to use a BiPAP machine. I wear a BiPAP machine at night. It blows additional air into my lungs with each breath I take. I will use it more and more during the day as my ability to breathe becomes more compromised. Eventually, the BiPAP will not be enough to sustain me and that is when I must decide if I want to have a tracheostomy and be put on a ventilator.

A tracheostomy is a surgical procedure in which a hole is cut in the front of the neck into the trachea. A tube is inserted and a ventilator will be attached that will do the work of breathing for me. The tracheostomy could extend my life for years. I will need more care and my disease will still progress. I might reach the point of losing all muscle movement, including blinking my eyes, and be unable to communicate. I would be what is called “locked in” with an active mind but completely motionless. In a 2004 New York Times article a doctor reported that 90 percent of ALS patients choose to die rather than accept a tracheostomy and ventilator.

The decision I have to make raises many questions. What is a “natural death?” I always assumed I would die when my life was taken from me. When I was sick enough to die, I would die at home in my own bed surrounded by my loved ones. My heart would stop beating or pneumonia would kill me or organ failure of some kind would end my life. I would not want tubes and monitors and intravenous lines that would prolong my life but decrease its quality.

Is it a form of suicide to refuse life-saving but invasive surgery such as a tracheostomy? I have accepted the placement of a feeding tube through my chest wall and into my stomach. I would already be dead without it. When do I say, “No,” to additional procedures and technology such as an internal catheter, intravenous feeding and hydration, and being bed bound 24hours a day? Life is a great gift, but is it wrong to passively let it go when it becomes miserable?

fines “quality of life?” Surely, the answer will be different for different people, so what defines quality of life for me? I know what I want to avoid: chronic pain, social isolation, uselessness and unending boredom. What positive things are my requirements to keep living?

What makes my life worth living? The things that I enjoy now are visits from my daughters and friends and my writing. My faith is a tremendous comfort and challenge, and a deep source of joy. When my daughters move away, will it be enough to see them a few times a year? Are my friends enough to sustain me when I can no longer communicate with them? Will they be comfortable visiting when all I can do is stare at them? When I cannot move at all will writing be enough, assuming technological advances make it possible? When all I have left is God, will that be the time to “let go and let God” take my life?

When is enough, enough?

http://www.citizen-times.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2010310030013
 
Last edited:

almost ready

Inactive
A dear family friend passed from this illness some years back. He had the most amazing composure and good nature. He died as he lived, a great neighbor, a good friend, one who gave, cheerfully, more than he received.

Forego the tracheotomy and let the disease progress. Is this Tom Swift a friend of yours, Farmer John? It's hard to realize, but whether the disease is a terrible sorrow or merely another stage in life to walk through comes from within. Try not to wimp out when you're with him. He needs your strength and courage to maintain his own.
 

Mixin

Veteran Member
My mother and I had many brief end of life talks, brought on by some of the tv episodes. She always said when her time came, I should just let her go. She wanted no tubes and no lengthy hospital stay. Those talks made it so much easier for me to make decisions when her time came.

I see the brave battles advanced breast cancer victims go through to buy time and I wonder if I would have the courage to follow in their paths.

Committing suicide is against my beliefs but I wouldn't have any religious quandries about refusing advanced medical treatments; especially if quality of life was poor and there was no cure in sight.

It would be nice if we could all just go gently in our sleep, after having spent a wonderful day with those we love.
 

georgia101

Veteran Member
This is a decision that we each must make for ourselves. ALS is a very hard, trying disease. It takes most everything away from its victims.
 

Burntfish

Inactive
Allowing yourself to die without massive medical intervention is NOT suicide.

Everyone must decide for themselves the quality of life that is acceptable before extreme medical procedures are withdrawn or withheld.

Personally, if I am not able to get up and do things for myself and enjoy life I want to be given large doses of pain medication so that I am not in any pain or distress and let me go. I do not believe in "life at any cost". We are all going to die.

Having said that, I have had many surgeries to fix problems...but I returned to a good quality of life afterward...so I am not against treatment if it can improve my health. :ld:

Fish
 

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
FJ, please note that euthanasia, refusal of care, and assisted suicide are all separate issues, and should be discussed as such, in this, as well as any other similar threads.
 

SarahLynn

Veteran Member
Allowing yourself to die without massive medical intervention is NOT suicide.
Everyone must decide for themselves the quality of life that is acceptable before extreme medical procedures are withdrawn or withheld.

Personally, if I am not able to get up and do things for myself and enjoy life I want to be given large doses of pain medication so that I am not in any pain or distress and let me go. I do not believe in "life at any cost". We are all going to die.

Having said that, I have had many surgeries to fix problems...but I returned to a good quality of life afterward...so I am not against treatment if it can improve my health. :ld:

Fish

You said this very sensibly I think, thank you.

I don't know how many are aware of this, but Pastor James MacDonald, the Christian minister who does the "Walk in the Word" radio broadcast out of Elgin, Illinois (Chicago area) has a similar story. His mother recently died of ALS and although she suffered as much as any ALS victim, she was able to communicate to within a few months of her death through a special writing pad set up for her. I don't believe the family took extraordinary measures to prolong her life at the end. James shared the story of her life and her struggle on his website and it was very moving to say the least.
I think I'd do what they did and what Burntfish suggests-take pain medication and not prolong the inevitable through heroic means.

I also agree with what Dennis said that refusal of care and euthanasia are separate issues which are usually confused in the public's mind and may be helping to promote the advance of euthanasia.
 

zeda1

Senior Member
You say "no more" when the quality of your life becomes unbearable to you. Nobody else can say when that will be for you. A trach can make the work of breathing easier but it is also a source of infection and needs frequent care. Quality of life is your definition.
 

dero50

Veteran Member
This is all true as long as we are making our own choices and not the government or some group,council, etc. We must retain the right to choose for ourselves.
 

NancyJo

Membership Revoked
I have worked and taken care of persons with ALS, It will not get better, ever. People have to make a clear, in a health directive ,what they wish. We can keep them breathing, but other functions fail, including spech, eyesight, any movement at all including bladder and bowels. I liken it to be inside the casket with the bell pull but not able to lift an arm to pull it. It's a slow aganizing death, I personaly would want it over sooner than later. JM2CW
 

RedheadGI

Contributing Member
I don't post much, but this is a very timely discussion for me, and I thought my experiences might help others.

My Mom, who has lived with me for the past year, was just diagnosed with a recurrence of breast cancer in her skull, spine and thigh. I know it is not the same as AlS, which must be a terrible disease, but it is a terminal diagnosis, nonetheless.

She is funny and brave and always prepared. I am one of six surviving children and we are all close by. She did a bit of radiation to help with pain, but other than that, has decided to forgo all other treatment other than hospice. Her wishes are well documented and I have never seen a person more at peace. Just today, I took her in her wheelchair out to hear a band she likes, and she got herself up to dance. Her smile lit up the room.

There are ways, if you have a bit of time to prepare, to die in a very dignified, comforting, loving way. I am watching it unfold.

My heart goes out to those struggling with their own end, or that of a loved one, but I have been surprised to find how much peace and joy can be found in death on one's own terms...
 

FarmerJohn

Has No Life - Lives on TB
FJ, please note that euthanasia, refusal of care, and assisted suicide are all separate issues, and should be discussed as such, in this, as well as any other similar threads.

I'm not suggesting that Pastor Swift be subjected to euthanasia, but many people will link that subject to the other two. Many people would call refusal of care by someone who could probably live reasonably comfortably for years more, to be a form of suicide.

My mother died from ALS. Hers was the 'fast' kind. She never needed the feeding tube because the interval between the onset of the difficulty of eating and the failure of adequate breathing was a matter of a only few days.

For me, the inability to communicate my own needs, ask someone to scratch that itch, move the arm that has gone to sleep or turn the page/change the channel or hit the mute button would be as bad as any intractable pain, made all the worse by an alert mind. I understand why most ALS patients forgo the respirator.
 

summerthyme

Administrator
_______________
I think the problem is there is no real way to tell how much "good time" - if any- will be gained by using a mechanical ventilator. And once a person is ON a vent, legally terminating it can be difficult. *Not even mentioning the emotional impact of essentially "turning off" a conscious loved one*

My youngest son's wife has an aunt who chose the vent... her ALS progressed quite quickly after diagnosis.. less than 2 years from her first symptoms to needing the feeding tube and vent for survival. She's completely bed bound or in a recumbant wheelchair, totally unable to communicate, although she can hear and see... if someone turns her head for her so she can look at something. Her care has nearly bankrupted her family (husband and three grown kids) despite good insurance. And the family is very worried that her husband may end up dying before her- a formerly robust man in his mid- fifties, he's so exhausted from the constant care needed (even though at least two of the kids have quit their jobs to help, and they get some respite care as well) he's barely a shadow of his former self.

I can't see it, personally. If, God forbid, I ever ended up with that disease or something similar, I'd live as long as possible *as long* as I could breathe, eat and communicate. I'd refuse a feeding tube and absolutely refuse a vent. I'd request that any physical distress caused by hunger or air hunger be treated with morphine and that they let me go Home. I have no fear of death... it's the dying process that can suck. And I have no wish to impose years of struggle, financial hardship and suffering on my family when there is no hope of ever recovering or even enjoying the tiny things in life.

Summerthyme
 

ainitfunny

Saved, to glorify God.
If and when you can do nothing else, you can pray, pray without ceasing, for praise of and thanks to God, for the needs of those you hear about one way or another, for your family, your friends, your pastor, your community, your nation and the world. There are too few prayer warriors. It too is a noble calling. Who knows how many people judged "useless", "brain dead", or "locked-in" are thus engaged in intercession with God for us? That counts, in my book.
 

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
If I were a vegetable like that (even if my mind were 100% clear), I wouldn't want to live. Death would be a blessed release for me at that point. Come Lord Jesus...
 

nharrold

Deceased
I think the problem is there is no real way to tell how much "good time" - if any- will be gained by using a mechanical ventilator. And once a person is ON a vent, legally terminating it can be difficult. *Not even mentioning the emotional impact of essentially "turning off" a conscious loved one*

My youngest son's wife has an aunt who chose the vent... her ALS progressed quite quickly after diagnosis.. less than 2 years from her first symptoms to needing the feeding tube and vent for survival. She's completely bed bound or in a recumbant wheelchair, totally unable to communicate, although she can hear and see... if someone turns her head for her so she can look at something. Her care has nearly bankrupted her family (husband and three grown kids) despite good insurance. And the family is very worried that her husband may end up dying before her- a formerly robust man in his mid- fifties, he's so exhausted from the constant care needed (even though at least two of the kids have quit their jobs to help, and they get some respite care as well) he's barely a shadow of his former self.

I can't see it, personally. If, God forbid, I ever ended up with that disease or something similar, I'd live as long as possible *as long* as I could breathe, eat and communicate. I'd refuse a feeding tube and absolutely refuse a vent. I'd request that any physical distress caused by hunger or air hunger be treated with morphine and that they let me go Home. I have no fear of death... it's the dying process that can suck. And I have no wish to impose years of struggle, financial hardship and suffering on my family when there is no hope of ever recovering or even enjoying the tiny things in life.

Summerthyme

That says it all...
 
Top