FOOD Grandma's Rhubarb Cream Pie

Raggedyman

Res ipsa loquitur
SPRING - - - tis the season of the pie plant - Rhubarb.

what I'm sharing below was my grandmothers recipe. the story is that during the depression she got it from an old Jewish lady who worked with her at McKelvey's department store in Youngstown, Ohio. I don't know if that's true or not - but its what I remember hearing - and I remember that when we were kids we'd beg her to make this pie because it was so incredibly good. it was ALWAYS on the table at family gatherings and it works really great alongside some vanilla ice cream. she'd make it in a big square glass pan - it would be about 2"thick and it had a lattice crust. when I get to see her again in heaven I'll bet she'll have a piece waiting for me on the table.

BEWARE:
this is the ORIGINAL depression era recipe . . . so it calls for 4 CUPS of sugar - Raggedyann uses splenda or some other sugar substitute - she's the baker and I don't know the conversions :shr: but I'm confident you'll be able to work it out :)


RHUBARB CREAM PIE

Crust:

4 cups flour
1 TBSP vinegar
1 3/4 cups shortening
1 egg slightly beaten
1 TBSP sugar
1/2 cup water
1 tsp salt

Mix flour, shortening & salt until crumbly. Mix in wet ingredients and save about 1/4 of the dough for the top. Roll out to fit a 9 x 13 pan.

Filling:
8 cups rhubarb, cut in 1/2“ pieces
4 cups sugar
8 eggs
6 TBSP milk
1 1/2 tsp nutmeg
1/2 cup flour
1 – 15 oz can crushed pineapple (drained) - OR - 15 oz frozen strawberries (drained).

Mix eggs, sugar, milk, nutmeg & flour together. Pour over rhubarb and pineapple (or strawberries) & mix. Pour into pie shell, dot with butter. Cut narrow strips of dough & weave on top of filled pie to create a lattice top crust. Bake @ 350 for 1 hour & 15 min. or until golden brown.
 

mecoastie

Veteran Member
Thanks. I will try this. Our rhubarb is just starting to pop up. Never been a family favorite although my son loves it dehydrated. I grow it because it is stock from my grandparents and it would be an important source of vitamins early in the year.
 

Raggedyman

Res ipsa loquitur
Thanks. I will try this. Our rhubarb is just starting to pop up. Never been a family favorite although my son loves it dehydrated. I grow it because it is stock from my grandparents and it would be an important source of vitamins early in the year.

I understand that very well. the rhubarb crowns I have here in WNC came originally from my grandfathers house in Ohio. they were originally planted in their yard circa 1915. my parents moved them and now they are here with me in WNC. I can't tell you how many times I have divided them and given away pieces of crown to others. I also have his Italian hard neck garlic and his Roman pole bean seed. it means a great deal to me to have these things left from them and to use them every year. I

I can guarantee you will love the pie!
 
I just checked my Betty Crocker cookbook, and those 4 cups of sugar look OK....Betty's recipe calls for 4 cups of rhubarb with 1 1/3 to 2 cups sugar....depending on how sweet you want it.

I am surprised at so many eggs....Betty's recipe uses none, although her rhubarb custard pie uses 3 eggs.

I'll stick with Betty's recipes...they are tried and true. I got her first cookbook edition when I got married as a very young gal. As many cookbooks as I have, hers is usually the first one I reach for.

She has come out with new editions, quite a few times, since then. I have most, if not all of them. And, more other cookbooks than I care to confess to...I really need to downsize, but they are just like old friends! How can I abandon them?
 

Raggedyman

Res ipsa loquitur
You know we have a room dedicated to food and recipes, right?


its already there - infact I put it there first but didn't think it would be seen very well. . . since the rhubarb is just now coming up I thought peeps would want to take a shot at this. please feel free to move and combine them - what ever you deem appropriate. I will now proceed to the fo'c'sle for keel hauling at the appointed time . . .
 

Raggedyman

Res ipsa loquitur
I just checked my Betty Crocker cookbook, and those 4 cups of sugar look OK....Betty's recipe calls for 4 cups of rhubarb with 1 1/3 to 2 cups sugar....depending on how sweet you want it.

I am surprised at so many eggs....Betty's recipe uses none, although her rhubarb custard pie uses 3 eggs.

I'll stick with Betty's recipes...they are tried and true. I got her first cookbook edition when I got married as a very young gal. As many cookbooks as I have, hers is usually the first one I reach for.

She has come out with new editions, quite a few times, since then. I have most, if not all of them. And, more other cookbooks than I care to confess to...I really need to downsize, but they are just like old friends! How can I abandon them?

MMJ
two things - this is cream not custard - and the size of this pie is pretty big 9 X 13 X 2 . . . could either of those be the reason for the difference?
 

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
its already there - infact I put it there first but didn't think it would be seen very well. .
FYI, the best way to do this is to post a “reference thread” on Main. Say something like “I’ve posted a fantastic recipe for (whatever) in Granny’s Kitchen. Here’s the link.”

Then post the link. Works like a charm.
 

Raggedyman

Res ipsa loquitur
FYI, the best way to do this is to post a “reference thread” on Main. Say something like “I’ve posted a fantastic recipe for (whatever) in Granny’s Kitchen. Here’s the link.”

Then post the link. Works like a charm.

thanks boss - do I do that now or leave it? can you move it and dump/merge the threads? I will be back later afternoon to do what ever needs to be done.
 

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
Meh - just leave it. But by having a detailed thread AND a reference thread, you keep most of the comments on the detailed thread, which is kinda where you’d want them for future reference.
 
Top