PLAY Your favorite Star Trek franchise and episodes

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
I called Discovery “Woke Trek” after I saw their free teaser eps. I’ve never joined their pay service for that kind of shit.
 

CaryC

Has No Life - Lives on TB
TOS and "The Trouble With Tribbles".
Just watched an episode of "Enterprise" and the doctor fed a Tribble to one of his pets. Reminded me of feeding cows to Raptors.

And on the new movie's Bones was killing one to see if he could bring it back from the dead. Saved Kirk's life.

I mean really how horrible are these people?
 

Tex88

Veteran Member
Actual ST fave: DS9

Kinda ST-ish fave: The Orville. But then again I also think Z Nation was a better series than The Walking Dead.
 

Hacker

Computer Hacking Pirate
Okay, more than anything else, I like the movies with TOS crew. I like the Voyage Home as the best film of this franchise.

Yeah, I know. I didn't list out a TV series. So sorry. ;)
 

OZARK

Senior Member
I watched the city on edge of forever a couple of days ago

Kirk goes back to 1930 and falls in love with Joan Collins
 

energy_wave

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Star Trek Picard season 3 sure seems a little like what is happening in this world. Episode 5 is interesting. A sinister power infiltrating Star Fleet (USA) at the top levels of command. Like the CCP, imo. Someone is embedding hints in the movies maybe?

 

ComCamGuy

Remote Paramedical pain in the ass
The wife and I love lower deck, TOS and TNG fan mostly otherwise. Favorite episode ever, EnemyBelow.
 

babysteps

Veteran Member
TNG, hands down. I did like Voyager but TNG was and always will be my favorite.

I don't know if I have a favorite episode. I was 11 when TNG began, so I simply loved everything about it, and still do.
 

TKO

Veteran Member
My answer will go in this post, but I’ll be making several revisions because for me at least, the answer is complex. That being said:

I started out as a hardcore TOS (the original series) fan. When TNG (the next generation) came along, and once the very shaky first couple seasons had gone by, I gained a real appreciation for Picard’s personality over Kirk. Where Kirk was basically a “cowboy,” Picard tried to use diplomacy and guile to gain the upper hand in conflicts. In the end, TNG won out over TOS, but it was a long, tough sell. TNG ended up being my second favorite franchise, with TOS being number 3.

When DS9 (deep space nine) was in first run, I only watched it a couple times. I felt that the storylines were weak and the characters wishy-washy. Further, Dr. Bashir pissed me off regularly because A) he was a womanizer, and B) he NEVER SHUT THE HELL UP. I felt that Captain Sisko wasn’t a strong commander. In sindication, I learned to moderately enjoy the series, but honestly, only a very few eps were worth it to me. That opinion remains to this day: DS9 is my least favorite.

Next is VOY (Voyager) with Kate Mulgrew as Captain Janeway. During first run, I watch two eps and refused to watch it again. It was painfully bad IMO. First, Mulgrew’s voice sounded like someone who’d smoked for 40 years. I actually couldn’t stand to hear her speak. Then there’s Tuvoc, a BLACK Vulcan (spare me.) Then Nelix the Talaxian, who was a manipulator and liar in the beginning. And the outrageously annoying doctor! I hated his arrogant ass with a purple passion. The list goes on. Anyway, one time YEARS later, I had nothing to do one weekend, so I started binge watching it. Shockingly, I found myself enjoying it, and eventually really liked it. I even got past Mulgrew’s voice. Voyager became my favorite franchise.

When ENT (Enterprise) aired (it’s a prequel series to TOS), I watched a few eps then quit. I couldn’t get used to Scott Bakula being the lead. I can only place him in Quantum Leap, a show that I found refreshingly different, and in which his performances were great. I never felt the cast gelled together the way they did in the other franchises. The biggest single turnoff for me was Bakula’s Captain Archer was always sticking his nose in where it didn’t belong, or where he wasn’t wanted. He was arrogant and smugly superior. And he didn’t get better as the series went on. I always wanted to reach into the TV, grab him by the collar, and bitch-slap him. ENT is my 4th in rank of the franchises. I ended up watching the entire franchise in fits and starts.

Now I’ll try to figure out my favorite episodes. I’ll edit this post as I come up with them.


Favorite episodes

TOS

Mudd’s Women
Dagger Of The Mind
Balance Of Terror
Shore Leave
A Taste Of Armageddon
Errand Of Mercy
City On The Edge Of Forever
Amok Time
A Piece Of The Action
Who Mourns For Adonais
Spectre Of The Gun
Wink Of An Eye
Elian Of Troyius
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield


TNG:

The Perfect Mate
Darmok
Tapestry
11001001
The Neutral Zone
Elementary Dear Data
Q Who (the first “Qpisode”)
Deja Q
Remember Me
Data’s Day
Qpid (this is the Sherwood Forest one)
Hero Worship
Cause and Effect (very good ep)
The Perfect Mate (Famke Janssen’s debut in film)
I, Borg
The Inner Light (voted best TNG episode)
Time’s Arrow (perhaps my fav)
Relics (James Doohan is in this one)
A Fistful of Datas
Chain of Command
Ship In A Bottle (companion episode to Elementary Dear Data)
Tapestry (also a huge fav)
Thine Own Self

VOY

The 37’s
Twisted
Lifesigns
The Thaw
Tuvix
Future’s End (Ed Begley Jr. is in this one)
Distant Origin
Year Of Hell (Kurtwood Smith is in this one)
Mortal Coil
Message In A Bottle
Demon
Living Witness
In The Flesh
Course: Oblivion (companion to Demon)
One Small Step
Fair Haven (this ep was critically panned, but I loved it)
Blink Of An Eye
Spirit Folk (companion to Fair Haven)
The
Haunting Of Deck 12
Shattered

DS9

The House Of Quark
Destiny
Little Green Men
Trials And Tribble-ations
The Magnificent Ferengi
Waltz
Honor Among Thieves
In The Pale Moonlight
His Way
It’s Only A Paper Moon
Badda-Bing, Badda-Bang
Extreme Measures
What You Leave Behind, part 2

ENT

None
I will say that the "Inner Light" episode, from Next Generation, is my favorite. It always seems to get the nod for best episode. I like most of the Borg episodes, too. I'm still a big fan of the original series. "My God Jim, I'm not a magician! I'm just a plain old country doctor."
 

PghPanther

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Don't follow Star Trek much but like the movie where the whales were trying to tell them to get back and save Earth's biosphere.
 

WalknTrot

Veteran Member
Picard Season 3... after that TOS and DS9.
This season of Picard IMHO has been the best so far. That is if you can get past how stinking old they all are. :lol:
With the Doc, Picard's kid, Riker, Seven, and even the "kids" of some of the old timers like Geordie. Good story.
Adding: Worf aged out very nicely, thank you very much!

My faves..have to be TOS and TNG. Really sorta quit paying attention after that.
 
Last edited:

Blacknarwhal

Let's Go Brandon!
DS9 is still my favorite, particularly after it discovered its stride as a World War II allegory. Those last few seasons when it was all-Dominion-all-the-time were really the best of DS9. Making the Ferengi into something real was terrific. I loved every Ferengi episode; wanted to see more of these strange little money-grubbing goblins trying to carry on in a post-scarcity universe.

Lower Decks, my second favorite, is Star Trek as a comedy, which I never imagined possible. And turning the Pakled into a viable threat was a stroke of utter mad genius.

Third favorite is Next Generation. Loads of great stuff. Picard is still the best captain ever. New worlds, new civilizations, and boldly going aplenty. Wesley can be forgiven. Maybe a smidge too much facile technobabble to solve a problem; how often did they solve something basically by muttering a lot of science words and then doing something they'd never actually do again in the series? Like bringing Geordi and Ro Laren back into phase?

Prodigy is interesting. It's Trek for kids, yet it does fairly well for adults. A good family Trek, which is by itself a novel idea. A lot of unanswered questions as yet, but some good ideas, and it might turn out nicely.

Strange New Worlds is doing all right, so far. I look for the tragedy of woke to slip in at some point, but I don't remember a lot of it after the first season. Nice effects, interesting plots--the Gorn? Novel!--and Christopher Pike doesn't do half bad as a white-guy captain. It's amazing they didn't make him gay or something.

Picard fared pretty well. An alternate universe plot for most of the second season? I wasn't sure if this was the Mirror Universe or just A mirror universe, but it did all right. First season wasn't great, second season picked up nicely.

Enterprise was honestly kind of a dark horse, but it was interesting to get a sense of Starfleet just starting out. Back before every problem could be solved by bouncing a graviton particle beam off the main deflector dish, this was Starfleet by the seat of its pants. A real frontier spirit, making do and really going boldly.

Voyager tried...but it just couldn't fire. Sure, the Krenim were novel enough, and this much Borg can never be a bad move. But it depended way too much on scientific phenomena as the bad guy, and I couldn't get behind it. Most of the crew was unlikable, from the Paris-and-Kim-Show to Admiral Insaneway, who made sense running some nobody-cares science vessel off in the hinterlands, but not someone you wanted to follow from week to week.

The Original Series had some high points, but man, it aged poorly. Half the sets were cardboard and most of them had William Shatner's teeth marks in them. Like Voltaire said: "What is with the Klingons? Remember in the day, they looked like Puerto Ricans and they dressed in gold lame. Now they look like heavy metal rockers from the dead! With leather pants and frizzy hair and lobsters on their heads."

Discovery was nothing but a constant rolling dumpster fire of disappointment. The most beautiful effects I'd ever seen squandered on gay weddings and a Girl Named Michael. Life wasn't easy for a boy named Sue, but a girl named Mike made things bad for EVERYBODY. Not even the Mirror Universe could save this slop. And I can't make it through the fourth season, which is basically the Everybody Goes To Therapy arc.

I think that covers the list.
 

Pebbles

Veteran Member
I adored the original Star Trek. I loved each episode but my absolute favorite episode was "The Metamorphosis". It starred Glen Corbett. He was Zafram Cochrane who fell in love with The Companion.
 

sssarawolf

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Original show for me as well. To me Picard acted like a dead fish or they had him acting like a pharaoh or something, stuffed shirt. Dh growls when he even gets a glimpse of the guy, lol.

The imagination for it and acting got worse and worse.

We watched the other offshoots but they just weren't as good and a couple of them ended really lamely.

The movies, oh my goodness the kids watched the Wrath of Khan so many times I think we all knew it by heart.

There my 2 cents.
 

danielboon

TB Fanatic
This season of Picard IMHO has been the best so far. That is if you can get past how stinking old they all are. :lol:
With the Doc, Picard's kid, Riker, Seven, and even the "kids" of some of the old timers like Geordie. Good story.
Adding: Worf aged out very nicely, thank you very much!

My faves..have to be TOS and TNG. Really sorta quit paying attention after that.
agreed even though they are old it is a great series
 

tech

Veteran Member
TNG without a doubt. TOS was to hippie oriented and the later were too woke.
B5 was much better IMHO than any Trek series.
 

EastWest

Senior Member
All of the older franchises had some great episodes but this particular one stands out with me.
DS-9 In The Pale Moonlight, Season 6

Garak’s brilliance brings the reluctant Romulans into the Dominion War with some master spy craft. He reminds Sisko that he was unwilling to get his hands dirty, that’s why you called on me..

Graython Tolar was a great character
Tolar.jpg
 

Burt Gummer

Veteran Member
I liked TOS because that was my time. Could not stand Next Gen. Thought Picard would break out in Hamlet at any time. Hated it. Janeway=no way. Deep space 9 - forget it. Enterprise-never saw it until last year. I love it. I watch it every night on H&I on Dish and it is a great show. If you dont like Enterprise you haven't watched it enough to know the characters. A fantastic series.
 

NHGUNNER

Senior Member
I'll be in the minority with this opinion, but my favorite is Enterprise. I'm sure it has more to do with the state of mind I was in at the time of airing, but it was a welcome intrusion to my home that helped me at the time.

Re-watching it many years later, I can't really get into the show itself, but it rekindles the safe feeling it somehow gave me at the time.

It may not make sense, but it is what it is.

ETA: Funny that this post falls just below someone that liked the show as well.
 

energy_wave

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Star Trek Picard, they got rid of Data and Q in season 1 and 2. I think by the end of season 3 Picard will also be gone and there will be a final ending to the crew from Next Generation. I think Picard's new found son is being groomed for a spin off after Patric Stewart ends his series. Maybe Star Trek Son of Picard. There is a new Star Trek 4 with Chris Pines coming out. They shelved the 4th movie when the sales numbers went south. Around the time there was all the other scifi films competing for dollars. I'm glad they are making another one, but not sure what they will do about the loss of Anton Yelchin.

Star Trek Strange New Worlds is also under rated, although a bit woke. Still a good series but season 2 we have to wait until fall, iirc.

SNW's link below.

 

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
Like Voltaire said: "What is with the Klingons? Remember in the day, they looked like Puerto Ricans and they dressed in gold lame. Now they look like heavy metal rockers from the dead! With leather pants and frizzy hair and lobsters on their heads."
That was actually answered in a Voyager episode, as well as the DS9 ep “Trials and Tribblations”
 

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
You’re right! Phlox was kidnapped by Klingons and taken to a lab where they’d been trying to copy Dr. Sung’s augment experiments. Undoing the effects changed the “heavy metal” Klingons to the “puerto rican” Klingons.

Worf saying they don’t talk about it was in “Trials and Tribblations”. That was a fantastically done episode, blending TOS and DS9.
 

Blacknarwhal

Let's Go Brandon!
You’re right! Phlox was kidnapped by Klingons and taken to a lab where they’d been trying to copy Dr. Sung’s augment experiments. Undoing the effects changed the “heavy metal” Klingons to the “puerto rican” Klingons.

Worf saying they don’t talk about it was in “Trials and Tribblations”. That was a fantastically done episode, blending TOS and DS9.

Yep, that's it! I always that was weird. Most of Klingon science is trying to find better ways to kill things. Genetic experimentation seems "beneath" Klingons, somehow.
 
Top