HEALTH Woman trying to ‘live on light’ instead of food ends experiment

Sleeping Cobra

TB Fanatic
After dropping about 20 percent of her body weight, Naveena Shine, the 65-year-old Eastside woman who got worldwide publicity for trying to just live on light and no food, is calling it quits with her grand experiment.

Monday was Day No. 45 of no food, just water and tea “with a splash of milk.”

Shine had dropped to 126 pounds from her original weight of 159 pounds on her 5-foot, 4-inch frame.

She says she’s quitting on Wednesday in part because she’s run out of money, and part because of the public reaction.

“I was just asking a question, but there was just so much negative response that that means the question can’t even be asked,” she said.

She also says that she didn’t want to be responsible for others trying “Living on Light” without having their “belief systems lined up.” She says it’d like “giving a loaded shotgun to a baby.”

Shine says she simply wanted to know if “breatharianism,” a New Age belief that sunshine can substitute for food, was possible. She posted about her experiment on Facebook, YouTube and her Living on Light website.

“I didn’t prove it,” she admits. But, says Shine, it certainly got people talking.

Doctors have warned that it is not possible for humans to photosynthesize, and four deaths have been linked to people who apparently had tried.

On previous days, Shine had reported feeling tired or dizzy, had thrown up after drinking water, felt twitches and had cold hands. But on Monday, says Shine, “I’m feeling totally fine.”

In recent days she had begun adding one packet of a vitamin supplement called “Emergen-C” to her water.

Shine had vowed to consider ending her experiment if she dropped to 125 pounds, and said she’d not go below 120 pounds.

Over the weekend, says Shine, she was dancing and even cleaned the small trailer that she rented for her experiment, located in a pastoral countryside setting. Friends would regularly check on her.

Another motivating factor, says Shine, is that she has run out of money.

The British-born Shine, whose original first name was Christine (she legally changed it to “Naveena,” Hindi for “new” in 1987), has led a vagabond life in which she has traveled the world.

Although trained as a teacher, and later earning a degree in psychology, she often worked as a waitress or caregiver wherever she happened to land.

She says she maxed out her credit cards buying such equipment as eight security cameras that she had installed in the trailer. She says they recorded her 24/7 to prove she wasn’t cheating on her no-food experiment.

Shine says she had hoped for contributions to help her defray costs, but that she had only received $425 in contributions through her website.

As for her first meal, she says it will consist of lemon juice for vitamin C and a spoonful of maple syrup in warm water for energy.

“I really have to start out slowly,” she says. After that, there’ll be “liquidy kinds of vegetables, like spinach or zucchini sautéed in water.”

In a few weeks, she might go to her favorite restaurant, Anthony’s HomePort in Kirkland, and have some fish.

Eventually, says Shine, she’ll be hitting the road.

She thanks those who were nice to her.

As for those with the vitriol, she says, “The haters, I think when people say something bad about somebody else, they’re really talking about themselves.”

http://seattletimes.com/html/localnews/2021211809_experimentendsxml.html
 

Giskard

Only human
What an idiot. She can afford food but not eat it? She should have been sending her food to those poor kids in Africa who have known little else that "living on light" for much longer than she! Doesn't she read the papers? Did she sleep through Biology 101 in High School? And what does "ran out of money" have to do with it? What is she now buying food with?
 

TerryK

TB Fanatic
What an idiot. She can afford food but not eat it? She should have been sending her food to those poor kids in Africa who have known little else that "living on light" for much longer than she! Doesn't she read the papers? Did she sleep through Biology 101 in High School? And what does "ran out of money" have to do with it? What is she now buying food with?

When I was a kid and didn't eat my veggies, it was "those poor starving kids in China" that was thrown in my face.
Now it seems Africa has taken it's place. :lol:
 

packyderms_wife

Neither here nor there.
why is this even news??? Seems to me this kind of clap trap would have been relegated to the National Enquirer.

K-
 

Countrymouse

Country exile in the city
So...she thinks she's a plant?

Well, what she did doesn't really sound all that far-out.....she basically did a 40-day fast, and at 5'4", and now 126 pounds. she's actually done a very good fasting diet that has brought her weight down to what it SHOULD be for her height.

The attempt to get $$$ for going on a fasting diet was merely her scam.

Glad it didn't work.

Now that her weight's down to its proper level, maybe she'll have the energy and health to seek an honest living.
 

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
She wanted to be the "ultimate vegan", and be one with the plants. Idiot. I knew this was a kaliforican before I opened the thread. The fact that she lives in Washington state is meaningless. She NO DOUBT came from the land of fruits and nuts.
 

vessie

Has No Life - Lives on TB
why is this even news??? Seems to me this kind of clap trap would have been relegated to the National Enquirer.

K-

Well, for the Seattle Times it is news.

The editor and reporters over at the Seattle Times do not live on a diet of "Living on Light", they subsist on a diet almost soley on grape and cherry flavored Kool Aid. They're on a "liquid air" diet if you will...

It is an ultra liberal clap trap news rag that has lost alot of readership. V
 
Last edited:

vessie

Has No Life - Lives on TB
She wanted to be the "ultimate vegan", and be one with the plants. Idiot. I knew this was a kaliforican before I opened the thread. The fact that she lives in Washington state is meaningless. She NO DOUBT came from the land of fruits and nuts.

And of course being in the Socialist State of Washington, one of her fellow white liberals in the DSHS here in King County will give her an EBT card so she can like many who have those here in western Wa., not only buy food but can get booze, tatooed and a lap dance all on our dime here in King County.

So she says she spent most of her airy fairy life traveling the globe. Good for her, I'm glad she got to 'see the world' but she now finds herself 65 and broke. Did she ever put a thought into her retirement years? V
 

Dux

Veteran Member
Wow, the haters are here in full force. I guess the money part was proving to the world that she wasn't cheating, with the cams. She could have proven or dis-proven to herself only with a little less green required.
 

imaginative

keep your eye on the ball
This is in Washington State? Any sensible practitioner of breatharianism ought to know that there simply isn't enough sunlight there to live on
 

mistaken1

Has No Life - Lives on TB
So she says she spent most of her airy fairy life traveling the globe. Good for her, I'm glad she got to 'see the world' but she now finds herself 65 and broke. Did she ever put a thought into her retirement years? V


Yes she did .....

And of course being in the Socialist State of Washington, one of her fellow white liberals in the DSHS here in King County will give her an EBT card so she can like many who have those here in western Wa., not only buy food but can get booze, tatooed and a lap dance all on our dime here in King County.
V

We are her retirement ......

Rather than trying to live on light she would have been better trying to morph into light.
 

Kathy in FL

Administrator
_______________
She wanted to be the "ultimate vegan", and be one with the plants. Idiot. I knew this was a kaliforican before I opened the thread. The fact that she lives in Washington state is meaningless. She NO DOUBT came from the land of fruits and nuts.

Why not? She obviously has the brain power of a plant.
 

Dosadi

Brown Coat
Everyone does live on light.

It simply needs to go through processing by plants.

We then eat plant, animals that eat plants or animals that eat animals that eat plants.

Thus all of our food is naturally processed sunlight in various stated of refinement.

XD
 

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
So she says she spent most of her airy fairy life traveling the globe. Good for her, I'm glad she got to 'see the world' but she now finds herself 65 and broke. Did she ever put a thought into her retirement years? V


Old hippy/Earth mother type. The penultimate liberal. Liberals don't THINK, they EMOTE. And it's plain she's spent her entire existence on that level. Most people eventually grow up. Some don't. She's one of those. Too bad for her. Let her live on light. Fool...
 

vessie

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Everyone does live on light.

It simply needs to go through processing by plants.

We then eat plant, animals that eat plants or animals that eat animals that eat plants.

Thus all of our food is naturally processed sunlight in various stated of refinement.

XD

I prefer to eat my 'sunlight' that appears in the form of a tenderloin steak with a huge baked potato with butter and a big gob of sour cream (Tillamook brand of course).

Topped off with a thunderbolt like flash of bumble berry cobbler (our Canadian members know what this gift from Heaven is) and Tillamook brand Vanilla Bean ice cream.:D V
 

vessie

Has No Life - Lives on TB
This is in Washington State? Any sensible practitioner of breatharianism ought to know that there simply isn't enough sunlight there to live on

Yes, western Wa. is Not the best place to practice this discipline.

Rust yes, light no.

Kinda like not having enough oxygen in a fish tank, if you will... V
 

Dex

Constitutional Patriot
Actually this practice has been going on amongst the guru's in India for many years, maybe even centuries. The guru's will eat once in a while but they spend their lives in mediation, sitting in the sun, drinking only water primarily. It is not something a westerner should do or take lightly. It should not be approached as an experiment. It's a way of life of spending every waking moment in meditation. They do accept donations of food that their villagers will bring them as homage.

I'm not sure that most people would understand the spirit of it. It's more of a part of eastern religion that westerners can't relate to. Hinduism, Buddhism, Kundalini and Transcendental meditation and even minimalism.

For her to approach it in a new age, health conscious sense, she was not being realistic or understanding of the dedication or necessary level of enlightenment.
 

Cardinal

Chickministrator
_______________
When I was a kid and didn't eat my veggies, it was "those poor starving kids in China" that was thrown in my face.
Now it seems Africa has taken it's place. :lol:

When you (and I) were a kid, the "Cultural Revolution" was going on and the children were starving.
 

Dobbin

Faithful Steed
My dam never had a problem with making me eat my veggies.

This one though needs someone to take care of her. A full time watcher. With an electric button and an electric shock when this one does something to hurt herself.

I can think of an entire government department that is willing to step up to her plate. Health & Human SErvices?

They were made for each other!

Dobbin
 

Dozdoats

Deceased
As for her first meal, she says it will consist of lemon juice for vitamin C and a spoonful of maple syrup in warm water for energy.

Light

Lemon juice

Maple syrup?

Sounds suspiciously like something else... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master_Cleanse

Like the program pushed by Stanley Burroughs - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanley_Burroughs

I just read his grand-daughter's book about him - http://www.amazon.com/dp/B006SMD0OC. A criminally sick man... one of the more difficult books to read I've ever finished. A twisted, inside-out, upside down narrative from a mind that was mangled long ago by her grandfather's sick criminal weirdness.
 
Top